Louisiana’s Revenue Estimating Conference was rendered obsolete and the state’s finances thrown into a tizzy yesterday when the price of oil plunged to a negative $37.63 per barrel from the (adjusted for inflation) high back in 2008 of $148.93, a swing of more than $186 per barrel. Stephen Winham, retired State Budget Director, explains what it all means in his analysis below:
By Stephen Winham
If I offered to sell you 5,000 gallons of high quality gasoline (no ethanol) at 20 cents a gallon, but you had to take all of it today, would you take it? Before you say yes, ask yourself, “Where would I put it?”
Oil is traded as a commodity on the open market. Traders buy contracts to take oil at a price guaranteed for a specific period of time. These are futures contracts and they expire on a date certain. If an oil buyer or trader cannot sell the contracts to purchase by the deadline they have to take possession of all the oil for which they contracted. Current contracts for May delivery expire today (April 21).
A contango exists when the contracted price of oil exceeds the spot (current) price. This, of course, makes the contracts valuable only if the buyer thinks oil prices will rebound enough to justify taking it at the contract price – and, equally important, if they have someplace to store it. Because there is too much oil on the market with no place to put it, we entered the uncharted territory of, not just low, but negative prices.
Oil for delivery in May was being traded at over $18 per barrel Friday (April 17) and at $15 per barrel Monday morning. These were extraordinarily low prices, but by the afternoon sellers had to pay buyers $37.63 to take their contracts for May delivery. Again, these contracts expire today (April 21). Traders holding oil futures were paying buyers to take contracts off their hands at the risk having to take physical delivery of the oil, which most are incapable of doing. The only way traders can store oil is to lease facilities which are already at a premium because most are full. It is possible there will literally be no available commercial storage space by the end of this month.
Monday’s crash, while shocking, was temporary and some say largely technical because trading on May contracts was relatively light. Most trading yesterday was on oil set for June delivery. However, the effects and implications of the oil glut are real and have serious implications for both the near and longer range future.
OPEC has already agreed to production cuts and Russia and Saudi Arabia have supposedly agreed to do so in May. The U. S. government plans to buy as much oil as possible for storage in our strategic reserves. These things should help, but prices for June delivery will settle in the low $20/barrel range. Some oil producers, already suffering, cannot survive, even in the short run, if they have to sell that low.
Although December 2020 futures contracts are currently trading in the low 30s, that’s pretty low and the rise in actual prices is currently unpredictable because we don’t know when, or how fast, the negative effects on consumption of the coronavirus will let up. Consider that oil futures traded at over $65/barrel as recently as January and it is easy to see why futures at $30 are a bleak prospect for producers.
To the limited extent we need it, we are enjoying low pump prices. Nobody knows how long they, or some oil producers, will last.
[AN ASIDE: This crash we are talking about is in West Texas Intermediate crude, the U. S. benchmark. Not all oil futures contracts are negative. Brent Crude (the European benchmark) futures contracts, though also going down, traded at over $25/barrel Monday, but storage is less an issue with Brent because it is stored in oil tankers that can travel anywhere in the world.]
Read Full Post »