Prior to May 23, 2024, residents living along the 85-mile stretch along the Mississippi River between Baton Rouge and New Orleans had a reliable, affordable method of monitoring air quality as a means of measuring potentially deadly air pollution, thanks to the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
But on that date just over a year ago, Gov. Jeff Landry, with the willing assistance of a Republican super-majority in the State Legislature, took that away with the stroke of a pen when he signed into law the COMMUNITY AIR MONITORING RELIABILITY ACT (CAMRA).
Up until that time, citizens could monitor the air quality in their neighborhoods effectively, accurately and economically with the use of a monitor that cost only about $289 per unit. Sometimes even then, the EPA would even loan the equipment at no cost.
But then came CAMRA which overnight BANNED THE USE OF THE EPA-APPROVED MONITORING DEVICES in favor of equipment that cost as much as $58,691 per unit, effectively pricing the air monitoring practice out of the financial reach of community groups and individuals.
SENATE BILL 503 by Sen. Eddie Lambert of Gonzales and signed into law as Act 181 of 2024 was not, as with Donald Trump and his hawking of Teslas, cell phones, watches, Bibles and other Trump-branded paraphernalia, done as an overt attempt at personal enrichment of anyone.
Instead, it was a brazenly naked effort, pure and simple, by the petrochemical industry and the politicians it owns to shut up citizens suffering from respiratory illnesses brought on by years of toxic emissions. There is simply no other explanation to disqualify EPA-approved monitoring equipment as a means for citizens to determine the threats to the air they breathe.
One need only examine political contributions to the various political campaigns by oil and chemical interests to verify that assertion.
And wasn’t it former U.S. Sen. and Abraham Lincoln’s Secretary of War SIMON CAMERON who once said that “an honest politician is one who when he is bought will stay bought”?
Not only is it cost-prohibitive to employ the newly-approved equipment that the state now approves, but under CAMRA, community groups now face fines of up to $32,500 per day (up to $1 million for intentional violations) for so much as even talking publicly about evidence of airborne pollution.
Have Landry and the Louisiana Legislature ever heard of the First Amendment which guarantees, among other things, the freedom of speech? David Bookbinder, director of law and policy for the Environmental Integrity Project, was probably thinking the same thing when he said, “The Louisiana statute mandates that you can’t talk about air quality unless you’re using the equipment that they want you to use.” Unfortunately, he continued, “the equipment that they want you to use costs hundreds or even thousands of times more than perfectly good equipment that people can use to monitor the air in their communities.
In the aftermath of several Gulf Coast hurricanes and the COVID pandemic, an organization calling itself Micah 6:8 Mission was formed to distribute food, cleaning supplies and other necessities to victims. In 2022, the organization was awarded a federal grant to purchase two air-quality monitors to be used for testing for a variety of common air pollutants in exchange for its promise to share its information with the EPA.
Cynthia Robertson, executive director of Micah 6:8 Mission would post alerts on Facebook and fly a red flat outside her office so neighbors would know when it was best to remain indoors.
No more, however, in light of the threat of heavy fines for doing so. Add to that an even more devastating blow to air monitoring in Donald Trump’s proposed EPA budget which would eliminate grants for state and local air quality management, cutting that program’s funding from $235 million to zero for 2026.
Despite the data that show that residents along that notorious 85-mile stretch, home to more than 200 industrial – mostly fossil fuel and petrochemical – plants, have a 95 PERCENT GREATER CHANCE of developing cancer than the average American, your Louisiana Legislature and your governor have ripped away the only financially feasible method of monitoring air toxins.
One of those who voted in favor of CAMRA, State Sen. Blake Miguez (R-New Iberia), recently announced his candidacy for the U.S. Senate seat. That election is next year and Miguez, one of 30 state senators to vote for CAMRA, will be attempting to unseat incumbent Bill Cassidy.
That SENATE VOTE was 30-8 with one, Sen. Heather Cloud (R-Turkey Creek), deciding to take a walk on the vote. The bill sailed to equally easy passage in the House, passing by a VOTE OF 76-16 with 13 members absent for the vote.
LISKOW, which operates in five cities, including New Orleans and Baton, is a law firm that is focused on the energy and oil and gas industry. The firm sponsors THE ENERGY LAW BLOG and on June 5, 2024, it posted a story on the blog by four staffers that carried the headline announcing the passage of CAMRA, proclaiming it as “establishing uniformity for monitoring and parameters for date use.”
That, apparently is the only thing that residents of river parishes from Baton Rouge to New Orleans need to know, that it establishes “uniformity.”
The important thing to remember about that “uniformity” is that ethylene oxide is unsafe at any level of exposure. The EPA has determined that inhaling 11 parts per trillion (with a T) for a lifetime can produce one additional case of cancer per 10,000 people. The higher the concentration, of course, the greater the risk.
For cancer alley, the level, on average, is about 31 parts per trillion (roughly three times the threshold above which the EPA has determined cancer risk to be unacceptable), according that Louisiana Illuminator story and a team from Johns Hopkins University observed averages of more than 109 parts per trillion, in some cases as far as seven miles away from those spewing fumes of toxins.
But not to worry. SB 503, aka Act 181, has now established uniformity of measuring how deadly the air is residents are breathing.
Hell, I feel better already with the warm fuzzy feeling of just knowing that our state leaders are staying bought like the honest politicians they are.
Read Full Post »