| By guest columnist Don Siegelman The prosecution of Derek Chauvin is an anomaly in American jurisprudence. The use of excessive force by police resulting in the death of black citizens, tragically, is not unusual; yet holding police accountable is. How did our legal system get to this point? First, because grand juries are a secret proceeding, prosecutors have free reign; there’s no judge or a lawyer present representing the victim’s family. Secondly, in 1976, the United States Supreme Court, in the Imbler v Pachman case, gave immunity to prosecutors to achieve convictions virtually by any means necessary. As a result, prosecutors cannot be held civilly liable even when knowingly and willfully presenting false evidence or false testimony or withholding exculpatory evidence to indictment or convict the innocent or to let the guilty walk free. On January 4, 2010, while President Biden was Vice President, the U. S. Solicitor General argued to the U. S. Supreme Court, in McGhee v Pottawattamie County Iowa (2010), that “U.S. citizens do not have a constitutional right not to be framed.” President Biden should repudiate that proclamation. No United States citizen should be framed by its government. President Biden, through an executive order, can provide a measure of justice for Black victims of the use of excessive force by police, first, by ensuring that families of victims have a lawyer present in the grand jury. The President should also direct the U.S. Attorney General to inform all federal agents and prosecutors that while, at present, they may not be held civilly liable for presenting false evidence or testimony or withholding exculpatory evidence, nevertheless, if they are found to have done so, they will be fired. Moreover, he should ask the U.S. Attorney General: 1. To ensure all interviews of witnesses and targets be recorded and those recordings along with any “body cam” video be turned over to a lawyer representing the family of a victim of the use of excessive force by police. 2. Because the grand jury is a critical stage of a criminal proceeding, the victim’s family should have the right to have a lawyer present in the grand jury as a check on truth. 3. The family’s lawyer should be able to voir dire, to question potential grand jurors to ensure fairness, just as is done in all civil or criminal jury trials. Currently no one insures that grand jurors are racially balanced or that grand jurors are neutral in their feelings toward the people that they are to consider charging with a crime. 4. Furthermore, the victim’s lawyer should be enabled to object to evidence or proposed testimony by the government and offer evidence or testimony for the victim. Such issues would be decided by a judge, the same as in a civil deposition. If this due process safeguard is important where monetary damages are at stake in a civil proceeding, surely this due process safeguard should be in place where someone’s life is an issue. Such an executive order would strengthen faith in our judicial system and help deter the use excessive force by police. (Don Siegelman is the only person to hold all four Alabama statewide elective offices: Secretary of State (1979-1987), Attorney General (1987-1991), Lieutenant Governor (1995-1999), Governor (1999-2003). |
Archive for April, 2021
Former Alabama governor, victim of GOP grand jury manipulation, shares his views on grand jury system
Posted in Uncategorized on April 13, 2021| 1 Comment »
April fundraiser is like the Energizer rabbit: still going
Posted in Uncategorized on April 8, 2021| Leave a Comment »
Mitch McConnell wants corporate CEOs “out of politics,” the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) notwithstanding. But he wants to keep accepting campaign contributions from those same CEOs.
At LouisianaVoice, we’re not hypocritical: We actively solicit contributions from those who can afford it and we just as actively solicit their participation in the democratic process we call government in this country.
Unlike politicians, however, we don’t come around with our hands out on a constant basis. We hold our fundraisers twice a year – April and September.
It’s April.
Please help us pursue journalistic investigative reporting by contributing what you can – and no more. We’re striving to shine a bright light on the way in which your tax dollars are being spent. We’ve got a couple of pretty good stories we’re working on even as this is being written that will likely make the subjects a tad angry. But then our job is to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. It takes time and it takes money, however, to do this.
I’m retired, so I have the time.
I’m retired, so the financial funds are another matter.
To give by credit card, click on the yellow DONATE button to the right of this post. It’ll take you to my PayPal account (and you need not have a PayPal account of your own to do this). Or, if you prefer, you may send a check to: LouisianaVoice, P.O. Box 922, Denham Springs, Louisiana 70727.
Remember, LouisianaVoice is a 501(c)(3) non-profit, so all contributions are tax-deductible. Also, those giving $125 or more will received a signed copy of one of two of my books: Louisiana’s Rogue Sheriffs: A Culture of Corruption, or Bordello on the Bayou, a fictionalized account of the Baton Rouge Madam of a few years back. Be sure to state your preference and to provide your mailing address.
As always, thanks and let’s keep ’em honest.
Mitch McConnell orders corporate CEOs ‘out of politics’ except when it comes to his own campaign contributions
Posted in Uncategorized on April 8, 2021| 2 Comments »
In terms of pure chutzpah, you have to hand it to Mitch McConnell.
Corporate CEOs, he says, should “stay out of politics.”
His DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE from corporate influence comes after a couple of dozen corporations condemned a new, more restrictive election law enacted by the Georgia legislature and after Major League Baseball pulled the plug on the 2021 All-Star game from the state in protest of the legislative action.
Among the companies condemning the new law were Delta Airlines and Coca-Cola, both headquartered in Atlanta.
Of course, neither McConnell nor any of his other Repugnantcan colleagues have refused the generous, life-giving teat of corporate campaign largess funneled to them either in the form of contributions from individual corporate executives or through political action committees created in the aftermath of the Citizens United Supreme Court decision. I’ll get to the specifics of that in a moment.
“I found it completely discouraging to find a bunch of corporate CEOs getting in the middle of politics,” an indignant McConnell told a press conference in Kentucky earlier this week. “My advice to the corporate CEOs of America is to stay out of politics. Don’t pick sides in these big fights.”

But he wasn’t finished. “It’s jaw-dropping to see powerful American institutions not just permit themselves to be bullied, but join in the bullying themselves,” he said.
Unsaid was whether or not he considered Repugnantcans in Congress to be part of that bullying process of which he was so critical.
Then came the not-so-subtle threat: “Corporations will invite serious consequences if they become a vehicle for far-left mobs to hijack our country from outside the constitutional order,” he warned.

I mean, it’s not like Florida’s Repugnantcan Gov. Ron DeSantis awarded the Covid Vaccine distribution contract in Palm Beach County to PUBLIX GROCERY STORES after Publix contributed $100,000 to DeSantis’s campaign.
But that’s not Mitch, you say? You’re correct, of course.
Well then, let’s take a look at ol’ Mitch’s corporate campaign contributions for the election cycle just completed. In federal elections, of course, it’s (ahem) against the law for corporations to contribute directly to campaigns so I’ll list the contributions from corporate individuals first and PACs in parenthesis:
- Blackstone Group: $108,502 ($1,000);
- UPS: $102,570 ($5,000);
- KKR & Co. (global investments): $80,630 ($7500);
- NextEra Energy: $71,091 ($5000);
- Apollo Global Management: $53,575 ($10,000);
- Capital Group Companies: $59,250 ($0);
- Humana, Inc.: $48,383 ($10,000);
- Blue Cross/Blue Shield: $33,984 ($20,500);
- AT&T: $54,137; $0;
- GEO Group: $42,194 ($10,000);
- CC Clark, Inc. (bottlers of Coca-Cola in Mississippi and Kentucky – can you say irony?): $49,461 ($0);
- Eli Lilly & Co.: $48,639 ($0);
- Raytheon Technologies: $28,156 ($18,500);
- American Airlines Group: $46,432 ($0);
- United Health Group: $43,802 $0);
- Foley & Lardner (international law firm): $35,320 ($7,000);
- MetLife, Inc.: $36,938 ($5,000);
- JP Morgan Chase & Co.: $36,727 ($5,000).
Those are pretty telling, but when you look at industry contributions, you get an even better picture of how dependent McConnell and his fellow Repugnantcans are on corporate charity which is returned in the form of massive corporate tax breaks. Again, I list individual contributions followed by PAC contributions from the same group in parenthesis:
- Securities and investments: $1.6 million ($201,000);
- Lawyers/law firms: $1 million ($171,000);
- Health professionals: $912,000 ($217,300);
- Insurance: $705,500 ($354,200);
- Pharmaceutical/health products: $475,200 ($316,800);
- Hospitals/nursing homes: $651,600 ($122,600);
- Misc. finance: $626,600 ($69,500);
- Oil & gas: $486,300 ($197,500);
- Lobbyists: $651,100 ($16,850);
- Leadership PACs: $13,500 ($542,500);
- Education: $532,400 ($11,600);
- Health services/HMOs: $411,500 ($128,100);
- Business services: $500,250 ($12,500);
- Misc. manufacturing & distributing: $414,600 ($83,100);
- Air transport: $370,800 ($122,000);
- General contractors: $463,700 ($26,000);
- Commercial banks: $305,500 ($154,300).
Keep in mind, these are contributions for only one individual, Mitch McConnell, and for only one election cycle, 2019-2020. McConnell, by the way, received MORE MONEY from S&P 500 CEOs than any other candidate in a competitive Senate race in 2020 – more than $258,600 from 37 individual donors. Altogether, he received $67 MILLION in campaign contributions from all sources for the 2020 election cycle. Multiply that by 100 senators and 435 representatives (of both parties) – and a smattering doled out to challengers just to hedge their bets – and you get a picture of what is shelled out every single election cycle just to keep the fat cats fat.

It’s enough to make you wonder if all that campaign money and money spent lobbying Congress could be put to better use like oh, say, education, infrastructure, health care, the environment.
But then, that would necessitate corporate CEOs getting involved in politics and we just can’t have that.
Just ask Mitch.
LouisianaVoice April fundraiser continues: please help
Posted in Uncategorized on April 7, 2021| Leave a Comment »
On Monday, I wrote that LouisianaVoice has for 10 years – and will always – call out elected officials when I feel they have betrayed the trust placed in them when they were elected.
Some might say my story below on Steve Scalise was pretty easy pickings, given that he participated in an invasion of the U.S. Capitol that may well have helped inspired the riotous insurrection that occurred 14 months later. But the truth is with yesterday marking the three-month anniversary of that attempt at undermining democracy, I felt it more than appropriate to recall Scalise’s participation in October 2019 breach of security that also involved overrunning Capitol security.
This is the mission of LouisianaVoice. Be it a member of congress, a sheriff, the head of Louisiana State Police, the president of a local school board, the athletic department of LSU or the State Board of Dentistry, wrongdoing, malfeasance, misfeasance, or outright theft by any public official will be exposed if I hear about it and can prove the facts.
I won’t deal in hearsay or gossip but I will continue to shine light into the darkest corners of this state when appropriate.
To do so requires investments of time and money. I have expenses. As pointed out earlier, I recently had a $5,000 legal bill stemming from legal work involving the pursuit of records from an agency that didn’t wish to surrender them. Of course, the agency in question – as is the case with most public agencies – charges for copies of documents.
That’s why I come to you twice a year – in April and September – with hat in hand, asking for your help. I don’t ask that you give more than you can readily afford. I would never do that. If you can’t afford to help, no problem. You will still have our stories to read free of charge. I don’t charge a subscription fee nor do I personally accept advertising (I still can’t control what the platform host throws up there in the way of ads and I realize nothing from those ads).
Please click on the yellow DONATE button to the right of this post to contribute by credit card. That will take you to my PayPal account (You need not have a PayPal account yourself). If you prefer, please send a check to: LouisianaVoice, P.O. Box 922, Denham Springs, Louisiana 70727.
Because LouisianaVoice is a 501(c)(3) non-profit, all contributions are tax-deductible and those giving $125 or more will get a signed copy of one of my two newest books: Louisiana’s Rogue Sheriffs: A Culture of Corruption, or Bordello on the Bayou, a novel based (very) loosely on the story of the Baton Rouge Madam. Be sure to provide your mailing address and your preference of books.
As always, thanks for your continued support.
14 months prior to Jan. 6 insurrection, another Capitol incursion led by LA. Rep. Steve Scalise opened the door
Posted in Uncategorized on April 7, 2021| 1 Comment »
Yesterday marked the three-month anniversary of the hostile invasion of the U.S. Capitol by supporters of the former guy bent on interrupting the official confirmation of the 2020 presidential election won going away by Joe Biden.
In terms of overt attempts to thwart the will of the electorate, this was an unprecedented event…were it not for an eerily similar event that involved a high-ranking member of the Louisiana congressional delegation more than a year earlier in the very same building.
The date was Oct. 23, 2019, when House Republican Whip Steve Scalise of Louisiana’s 1st Congressional District was joined by none-other than accused pedophile Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz and 39 OTHER REPUBLICAN HOUSE MEMBERS who literally forced their way past Capitol security guards (sound familiar?) into the Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF) to interrupt a deposition being given by a top Pentagon official overseeing U.S. policy in Ukraine.
To give a bit of background, protocol calls for tough screening of cell phones before they can be allowed inside the SCIF but that didn’t stop these 41 clowns, once inside, from not only bypassing risk-mitigation safeguards, but using their devices to ORDER PIZZA as if they were a bunch of college frat boys (and sorority girls) getting their kicks by pulling off some kind of bizarre prank.
It was about as serious a security breach ever recorded in the Capitol to that time and probably helped inspire the insurrection that took five lives on Jan. 6 of this year. The precedent had been set. As J.R. Ewing famously once quipped on the CBS-TV show Dallas: “Once you give up your integrity, the rest is a piece of cake.”
The Republicans have long since given up any shred of integrity and to know that a man being mentioned as a potential candidate for governor of Louisiana in 2023 participated in such a stunt is nothing short of shameful and certainly worthy of his being stripped of his committee assignments and revocation of his status as Minority Whip.
Click HERE to view a clip from Gaetz’s self-serving press conference staged during that 2019 SCIF invasion taken from Gaetz’s own congressional web page. Standing to Gaetz’s immediate right in the photo of Gaetz holding court is our very own Steve Scalise.
Folks, this isn’t typical Republican-bashing. This is serious business and it underscores just what a partisan hack Scalise really is. If he had any semblance of a soul left, he sold it long ago to his instincts of political self-serving with no thought given to the standards of behavior expected of members of Congress.
The simple fact is, no mater what your personal political philosophy may be, no matter what may be the collective thinking of your constituents, there are some things you just do not do and STORMING PAST CAPITOL SECURITY to pull off some sort of grandstanding security breach by forcing your way into a secure area should be at the top of that don’t go there list.
Scalise, by his PARTICIPATION IN THIS IDIOTIC STUNT, which itself bordered on sedition, has proven beyond any doubt that he does not possess the maturity or the political acumen to lead Louisiana as governor. He is certainly not worthy of serving as Minority Whip – though he does seem eminently qualified to represent the David Duke faction of the Republican Party comfortably ensconced in the congressional district he currently serves.


