LouisianaVoice has been informed that State Fire Marshal Butch Browning has been summoned to a meeting in the governor’s office next week.
There was no immediate indication what that meeting will be about but if the report is accurate, there are a couple of items the administration may wish to ask Browning about:
- Why did the office of State Fire Marshal (SFM) spend $4,649 in May 2015 to “up fit” the office’s special food service trailer for the purpose of supporting “events and emergencies with equipment for field food services when necessary,” but when the August 2016 flood struck South Louisiana, SFM agents say they had to fend for themselves because that food service trailer was nowhere to be found?
- Why did the SFM spend $4,900 in May 2015 as a deposit for LR3 Consulting of Baton Rouge to create a website for Louisiana Firefighter Proud when Louisiana Firefighter Proud is a private entity not affiliated with any state agency?
- Why is it that the SFM claims to have no record of purchasing drones for $7,500 each from a New York vendor when SFM agents insist they were purchased and training records for at least one SFM deputy lists an eight-hour course in drone training and safety compliance?
LouisianaVoice has attempted—unsuccessfully—to obtain answers to these questions.
When I inquired into the 10 washers and 10 dryers and the drones, I received the following response from the SFM’s legal department:
From: (Name redacted by LouisianaVoice)
Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2017 9:11 AM
To: Tom Aswell <azspeak@cox.net>
Subject: PRR: Louisiana Voice Request dated 8/8/17
Mr. Tom Aswell
PRR: Louisiana Voice Request dated 8/8/17
SFN: 00000-77
Dear Mr. Aswell:
With regard to the email below, your request to view ten clothes washers and dryers, the Office of State Fire Marshal has no washers and/or dryers at 8181 Independence Blvd., Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
Additionally, in your request you asked for receipts for four drones from B&H of New York at approximately $7,500 each. No such documents exist.
Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
Best Regards,
(Name redacted by LouisianaVoice)
Office of State Fire Marshal
8181 Independence Blvd.
Baton Rouge, LA 70809
So, if those washers and dryers are not at 8181 Independence Blvd. (SFM headquarters), where exactly are they and why can’t I be allowed to view them?
I posed that follow up question to the SFM’s office but have yet to receive a response.
It took a former employee of the SFM to clear up that little mystery. The washers and dryers, he explained, were not purchased but leased from Broad Base Service and Rentals in Harvey for $4,999.99, one cent below the minimum purchase amount that requires quotes from vendors. They were rented, he said, to wash the uniforms of deputies working the August 2016 flood of South Louisiana. The September 6 transaction date would seem to substantiate that explanation.
That same individual said he, too, had heard that Browning had been notified to appear at the governor’s office next week.
He also said no one at SFM is minding the store as concerns purchases on the state credit card. “You’re on the right track in checking those credit care purchases. There is absolutely no control over the expenditures in that office.”
I did receive a response to some of other public records requests, namely training certificates for four deputy fire marshals.
Without naming the individuals, I can say that some of the training courses appear to have little to do with inspections of amusement rides, boilers, nursing homes, hospitals, jails, or mobile homes, all of which are part of the SFM’s responsibilities.
In other states, each of those areas would be assigned to deputies specifically trained in those respective areas but in Louisiana, deputies under Browning are “cross-trained,” meaning they are expected to be proficient—and certified—in all inspection disciplines.
In examining the record of one deputy, I found a certificate for an eight-hour course in “Law Enforcement Chaplaincy” from an organization identified on his certificate as Compassion Ministries.
While this is by no means meant to disparage a deputy’s faith, there appears to be little connection between that certificate and building, ride, boiler or fire inspections or investigations.
I also found certificates for all four for such courses as ethics, preventing sexual harassment and defensive driving. As one who has taken each of these courses during my 20 years with the state, I can attest to their absolute uselessness—with the possible exception of the ethics course, which is only slightly more comprehensive. Still, those courses appear to be of little benefit to a SFM deputy working in the field, investigating fires, inspecting buildings, rides, and boilers.
Conversely, there were courses listed in that make it appear that Browning is attempting to turn the fire marshal’s office into a full-blown police force on a par with State Police:
- Drug enforcement training (16 hours);
- Narcotics investigations (48 hours);
- Hostage negotiation (four hours);
- Military police training (a five-month course);
- Traffic radar operation (four hours);
- Advanced criminal patrol tactics (eight hours);
- Chemical weapons familiarization (four hours);
- Use and handling of stringer spike strip systems (one hour);
- Shotgun familiarization (four hours);
- Drugged driver detection (four hours)
- Chemical testing for intoxication (16 hours);
- Police driving (24 hours);
- Taser certification (four hours);
- Unspecified FEMA training;
- Introduction to cultural diversity.
By contrast there were courses that seemed to be a bit more relevant, though the four deputies whose records we reviewed did all not seem to have the advantage of taking the same courses:
- Effective Investigation and Testimony (three hours);
- Investigating Fatal Fires (four hours);
- Commercial Building Code Fundamentals;
- Hazardous Materials Awareness (four hours);
- Firestop Seminar (three hours);
- Sprinkler Seminar (three hours)
- National Electrical Code Seminar (16 hours);
- Scientific Method of Fire and Explosion Investigation (three hours);
- Electrical Safety (three hours);
- Residential Electrical Investigation for the Fire Investigator (24 hours);
- Post Blast Investigators School (40 hours);
- Critical Thinking Solves Cases (four hours);
- Investigating Natural Gas Systems (three hours);
- Investigation of Commercial Kitchen Fires (eight hours);
- Residential Natural Gas Systems (three hours).
While there were records of only four deputies to review, it seemed odd that for a department stressing cross-training as does the SFM, there were no courses listed in boiler inspections, amusement ride inspections, nursing home or hospital inspections, or mobile home inspections for any of the individuals.
Louisiana Voice 