Feeds:
Posts
Comments

A two-hour public corruption forum in Abita Springs Thursday night produced little in the way of solutions to the growing problem of official wrongdoing in St. Tammany Parish but one question from an audience member did produce a buzz among the audience and some uncomfortable tap dancing from participants on the four-man panel brought in to address the issues.

The forum, presented by the Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany (CCST) was scheduled to have as participants District Attorney Warren Montgomery, Sheriff Randy Smith, Louisiana Inspector General Stephen Street, New Orleans Metropolitan Crime Commission (MCC) President Rafael Goyeneche, and representatives from the Louisiana State Police and the FBI.

The FBI and state police were no-shows and Smith sent his public information officer in his stead with the explanation that a family situation prevented his attending (although the family business didn’t prevent him from responding to a lawsuit against him and two of his deputies stemming from an unconstitutional arrest of a local citizen last September).

Street dominated the show, taking the spotlight from the others with long and convoluted answers to questions while Goyeneche explained the workings of the MCC whenever given the chance to speak.

Smith issued an online statement that he was confident that a lawsuit filed by former St. Tammany deputy Jerry Rogers for his arrest for criminal defamation, an offense long since declared unconstitutional by the Louisiana Supreme Court, “will prove to be frivolous and without merit.”

Smith went on to say, “It is a shame we must waste taxpayer dollars to defend such frivolous suits.” He called the suit “nothing more than another politically-charged stunt by members of the former Strain administration while neglecting to note he had been advised by Montgomery’s office before seeking Rogers’s arrest for sending emails critical of the department’s investigation of a still-unsolved murder in St. Tammany Parish that such an arrest was unconstitutional.

The fact that the attorney general’s office refused to pursue the case against Rogers apparently failed to register on Smith’s taxpayer waste-o-meter.

But the hot topic, brief though it was, was raised in the form of a written question sent forward by an audience member:

“Should a person of interest in a murder case who refuses to cooperate with authorities and who refuses to take phone calls from investigators be allowed to serve as a member of the Louisiana State Police Commission?”

The question, apparently directed at State Police Commission member Jared Caruso-Riecke, a St. Tammany Parish resident, sent an excited murmur through the crowd and sent panelists fumbling for a diplomatic, if uncomfortable response.

Caruso-Riecke’s business partner Bruce Cucchiara was gunned down in the parking lot of a New Orleans East apartment complex on April 24, 2012.

The murder remains unsolved.

Cucchiara worked for the RIECKE FAMILY in Covington and at one time ran the Southeastern Louisiana Water & Sewer Co., before it was purchased by the St. Tammany Parish government in a controversial 2010 DEAL.

Caruso-Riecke had a LIFE INSURANCE POLICIY on Cucchiara with New York Life totaling some $5 million, his children said.

Cucchiara also has signed a promissory note as security on some real estate property to Caruso-Riecke only 20 days before he was killed.

CAITLIN PICOU, Cucchiara’s daughter, said Caruso-Riecke gave an initial statement to investigators but since then, the detective “has reached out to him but he declined to speak. They’ve reached out to his lawyer, as well, and he’s declined as well.”

“This (Cucchiara) was his best friend and he (Caruso-Riecke) won’t cooperate with investigators,” Chris Cucchiara said.

But, he added, Caruso-Riecke told him and Caitlin that he’d deleted some of the elder Cucchiara’s emails in an effort to “clean up” any personal messages.

Picou and her brother, Chris Cucchiara said when police did not clear Caruso-Riecke, thereby freeing the life insurance company to pay the benefit, “he (Caruso-Riecke) filed suit. Chris Cucchiara also said he was told by investigators that they did not want to clear Caruso-Riecke, “but we got a lot of pressure from higher-ups who live on the North Shore (St. Tammany) that we need to release the money.

It’s not clear where such pressure was coming from, but despite investigators’ having not cleared him as being implicated in the murder, Caruso-Riecke SUED New York Life on Aug. 7, 2012 to obtain the benefits of the life insurance policy on his business partner. Inexplicably, he filed his lawsuit in federal court in Baton Rouge instead of New Orleans, which would have normally been the proper venue for a St. Tammany resident.

Regardless, New York Life apparently decided not to fight him and the lawsuit was DISMISSED in Caruso-Riecke’s favor on Oct. 1.

 

You can call last September’s arrest of Jerry Rogers several things:

  • Jerry Larpenter, Chapter Deux;
  • SLAPP;
  • Stupid;
  • All of the Above.

Especially stupid.

To refresh your memory, Rogers, a former St. Tammany Parish sheriff’s deputy, fired off an email to the family of slain Nanette Krentel that was critical of the official investigation into Krentel’s murder. Specifically, he leveled his criticism at lead investigator Det. Daniel Buckner, whom he described as “clueless.”

For his trouble, Sheriff Randy Smith directed that Rogers be arrested for criminal defamation, despite being advised by the St. Tammany Parish District Attorney’s office that the state’s criminal defamation law had been declared unconstitutional as to public officials, according to a LAWSUIT filed by Rogers.

Named as defendants in the litigation are Smith and deputies Danny Culpepper and Keith Canizaro.

The arrest and ensuing lawsuit evoked memories of Terrebonne Parish Sheriff Jerry Larpenter who pulled a similar stunt when he spotted an online blog critical of him and other parish officials and promptly had an obliging judge sign a search warrant empowering Larpenter’s office to conduct a raid on the blogger’s home and to seize his computers. Larpenter, in the glow of his triumph, albeit temporary, crowed that when one criticizes him, “I’m coming after you.”

Except, of course, the warrant and the raid were unconstitutional and Larpenter’s office ended up ponying up about $250,000 to soothe the ruffled feelings of aggrieved blogger.

Just the kind of thing to make one wonder where the judges involved obtained their law degrees and why they would sign off on warrants that were so obviously unconstitutional.

But when considering political expedience, the rule of law often takes a back seat to the sweet (but again, temporary) taste of revenge.

In legal parlance, such legal maneuvers are known as Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation (SLAPP), a tactic honed to perfection during the civil rights era by Southern sheriffs and chiefs of police, particularly in Montgomery and Birmingham, Alabama.

Former Gov. Edwin Edwards, when questioned about his observations immediately after Larpenter’s raid but before litigation had been initiated, quipped, “I’d love to be that blogger’s lawyer.”

Prophetic words indeed. A federal judge held in that case that “no law enforcement officer in Sheriff Larpenter’s position would have an objectively reasonable belief, in light of clearly established law, that probable cause existed to support a warrant for the Andersons’ home” because it was based on criticism of a public official.

Now it’s Jerry Rogers’s turn at bat against another ill-conceived move by a sheriff and district court judge, in this case, one Hon. Raymond Childress.

That’s because as early as 2014, the St. Tammany Parish Sheriff’s Office was reminded of the status of Louisiana’s criminal defamation law, the lawsuit says.

The president of the Louisiana Sheriff’s Association in 2014 “described arresting anyone for an alleged violation of an unconstitutional law as a waste of time and resources,” the lawsuit quotes a newspaper article as reporting.

“Sheriff Smith’s actions were intended to deter and chill Jerry Rogers’ exercise of his First Amendment right to express his opinion about STPSO,” Rogers’s petition asserts.

That, by the way, is a classic definition of a SLAPP lawsuit.

Not only did Judge Childress sign off on the AFFIDAVIT FOR ARREST WARRANT, but the St. Tammany Parish Sheriff’s Office even had the presence of mind to issue a self-serving PRESS RELEASE to announce its diligence in protecting its citizens from being exposed to such defamatory criticism and in the process, declaring its utter disregard of the law.

Except for the decision of the Louisiana Attorney General’s office to DECLINE TO PURSUE the case after noting that the Louisiana Supreme Court had “held [that] criminal defamation is unconstitutional insofar as it applies to statements made in reference to public figures engaged in public affairs.

“…[T]he statements made by Jerry Rogers were aimed directly towards a public function of a member of state government. Because the alleged conduct under these specific facts involve statements aimed at a public official performing public duties, this office is precluded by law from moving forward with any criminal action, Assistant Attorney General Joseph LeBeau wrote on January 8.”

So chastened, there was little wiggle room for the sheriff other than to WALK AWAY from his aborted attempt at retribution.

All of which served to invoke the third option in our multiple-choice observation at the beginning of this post:

Stupid.

 

“When the term executive time is used, I am generally working, not relaxing. In fact, I probably work more hours than almost any past president.”

—Donald Trump tweet, Feb. 10, 2019. (Cost to taxpayers for Trump’s golf outings: $127 million as of Feb. 2, 2020.)

 

Was LABI flim-flammed by a flim-flam artist?

Frank Abagnale, the subject of the Leonardo DiCaprio-Tom Hanks movie Catch Me if You Can, was the featured attraction—sort of like a carnival sideshow—at Tuesday’s annual Louisiana Association of Business and Industry (LABI) luncheon at Baton Rouge’s Crowne Plaza Executive Center.

Abagnale was billed as an expert on cyber security attacks but spoke mainly about his days as a career con man—a career some say continues today.

LABI not only forked over a reported speaking fee of some $20,000, but the organization also purchased copies of Abagnale’s two books, Catch Me if You Can and Scam Me if You Can in bulk quantity—most likely at a discount—and resold them to its adoring membership. Some of those members even posed for photos with the beaming author who, in his expensive suit and silver hair, came off as some elderly corporate CEO.

Which is probably how he intended it.

But one person who wasn’t impressed—or fooled—was Paula Campbell, a resident of Watson whose parents she says were taken for hundreds of dollars by Abagnale decades ago when he roomed at their Baton Rouge residence for several weeks.

PARKS STORY PART 1

PARKS STORY PAT 2

“I was a flight attendant for Delta Airlines at the time he was passing himself off as a TWA pilot, flying around the country as a deadhead (an off-duty pilot hitching a ride as a non-paying passenger) passenger,” Campbell said. “He gave me a ride from New Orleans to Baton Rouge so I could visit my parents.

“I found him creepy and offensive but my parents fell in love with his B.S. stories and invited him back. Several weeks later, he reappeared and they invited him to stay as their guest. While he was there, he stole cash from my brother who was working as a bag boy at a grocery store and he stole checks from my parents and forged them and cashed them.”

Campbell was at the LABI event and stood in line to purchase a copy of Catch Me if You Can. At the table, she told him who she was and asked him to sign the book to her late parents and to write, “Sorry,” because he had never apologized to them.

While he professed not to remember her, he did sign her copy of the book and wrote “Sorry” under his signature but faltered when writing the date as she challenged his failure to acknowledge in any of his talks that he’d been arrested in Baton Rouge. “That’s because I work for the FBI,” he explained as he appeared to avoid eye contact with her.

Which raises other questions about his claims as he travels around the country collecting generous speaking fees, which have mushroomed from $2000 in the early days to six-figure fees in the aftermath of the movie.

He suddenly developed a conscience about speaking to “young, impressionable minds” and canceled all scheduled college campus speaking engagements after being asked by officials at the University of South Carolina to sign a affidavit “attesting to the truthfulness of the speech he would give,” according to the Columbus (South Carolina) Daily Enquirer. “He refused,” the story added.

APPEARANCE CANCELED PART 1

APPEARANCE CANCELED PART 2

In canceling an appearance at Georgia Southwestern College in Americus, GA., he somewhat revealingly said that a college appearance would open him to “a great deal of unnecessary controversy,” the Daily Enquirer story said.

That seems a somewhat thin excuse, given the fact that Abagnale has professed to leading a life of considerable controversy for virtually all of his adult life.

Claims by Abagnale that he had defrauded banks of more than $2.5 million have been debunked as evidence by investigators could find leas than $1,000 in bad checks he had passed. Additionally, claims that corporations such as Sears, J.C. Penney, Chase Manhattan Bank and American Airlines have paid him a combined $10 million a year for crime prevention consultant work were likewise shot down when each of the companies denied any such consulting work by Abagnale.

Even easier to disprove was his assertion that he had been a professor of criminal justice at Rice University in Houston. Rice didn’t have a criminal justice program at the time the article was written in October 1982.

A year earlier, Fayette Tompkins covered an appearance by Abagnale at Tulane University in New Orleans for the Baton Rouge State-Times. Tompkins, now retired, wrote at the time that Abagnale claimed to have taken and passed the Louisiana Bar exam and had actually worked for nine months for the Louisiana Attorney General’s office under Attorney General Jack P.F. Gremillion.

TULANE APPEARANCE PHOTO 1981

TULANE APPEARANCE PART 1

TULANE APPEARANCE PART 2

The problem with that was Abagnale consistently mispronounced Gremillion’s name and no one at the AG’s office could recall a Bob Conrad (Abagnale’s supposed alias at the time) having ever worked there. Ken DeJean, now retired but then an assistant attorney general, said there were no records of any such person ever having been employed in the AG’s office.

Tom Collins, then executive counsel for the Louisiana Bar Association likewise could find no record of anyone by that name from Baton Rouge ever being admitted to the bar during that time period (the late 1960s).

In his claim, Abagnale said he won 33 cases in six months for the AG’s office, an impressive feat for an experienced attorney but extraordinary for an impostor who had dropped out of high school. Most attorneys I’ve known don’t even try nearly that many cases in so short a time. He contradicted himself in another story by saying that while at the AG’s office, he primarily served as a “gofer,” fetching coffee, etc. for the real attorneys.

Finally, there was that dismissive explanation he gave to Parks on Tuesday. “I still work for the FBI.”

All of which causes one to wonder just how well LABI vetted its keynote speaker before buying a few hundred copies of his book and paying him a hefty fee.

“Just run the presses—print money.”

—Donald Trump, to Gary Cohn, former director of the National Economic Council.

 

“This is the United States government. First of all, you never have to default (on debt) because you print the money.”

—Donald Trump, to CNN’s Chris Cuomo, May 2016.