Feeds:
Posts
Comments

The March fundraiser for LouisianaVoice continues and your help is both needed and appreciated.

We’re working on some pretty intriguing stories at LouisianaVoice, one of which is about campaign contributions by special interests for this year’s elections of statewide officials and legislators.

Like any reporting enterprise, sometimes we run into dead-ends (non-stories) and sometimes we break really significant stories, stories that other news organizations either ignored completely or literally took years to jump on board, like:

  • The series of Louisiana State Police stories under the administration of former Superintendent Mike Edmonson;
  • The story about Superintendent of Education John White’s plotting in an email to “take some air out of the room” during misleading testimony before a legislative committee, a story that a north Louisiana daily newspaper tried (incorrectly) to take credit for breaking;
  • About White’s plans to provide personal student data to a company controlled by RUPERT MURDOCH;
  • Our series of stories about widespread abuses by the Louisiana Board of Dentistry and the Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners;
  • Several stories about campaign contributions from special interests and how those contributions take precedent over what’s best for the people of Louisiana;
  • Stories about how campaign funds are misused for personal purposes like paying personal income taxes, purchasing season tickets to Saints, Pelicans and LSU games;
  • Abuses of power by certain sheriffs in Louisiana, notably Terrebonne Parish’s Jerry Larpenter and Iberia Parish’s Louis Ackal;
  • Critical investigative audits of state and local agencies that negatively impact the manner in which our hard-earned taxpayer dollars are misused, misappropriated, and at times, embezzled
  • The Jindal administration’s attempt at steamrolling a state agency head because he wouldn’t compromise state regulations for a major Jindal campaign contributor;
  • How major Jindal contributors appeared to have “bought” positions on powerful state boards and commissions.

I’m told that some legislators make faces and utter profanities at the mere mention of my name.

Thank you.

There are also countless stories that you will never know about because, well, they turned out to be dead-ends. But we nevertheless were forced to spend considerable time chasing down those blind leads and those efforts took time—and money.

That’s why LouisianaVoice needs your help. If you appreciate these stories, please do what you can to support our efforts.

I even invite those of you who disagreed with or were offended by certain stories. That’s certain to happen because no two people think alike on every single issue. There were be differences of opinion but I would hope my readers are open-minded enough to understand that what I do with LouisianaVoice, I do in the interest of transparency and accountability. If those two factors are removed from reporting, then democracy and freedom die. So, even if you take umbrage at what I write, I have at least laid the issue on the table for consideration and discussion.

So please. Do what you can by clicking on the yellow DONATE button in the upper part of the column to the right of this post or mail your check to:

LouisianaVoice

P.O. Box 922

Denham Springs, Louisiana 70727

Editor’s note: Last year, LouisianaVoice published a couple of stories about the indictment of Iberia Parish Clerk of Court MIKE THIBODEAUX and the political circus that seems to be the norm for Iberia Parish. The 14-count indictment followed a 2016 investigative AUDIT by the Legislative Auditor’s office. Coming two years after the audit, the indictment would appear to be politically motivated by Thibodeaux’s FIRING of parish Assessor Ricky Huval’s son, Ryan Huval. Ricky Huval’s daughter, Rachael, it turns out, is employed by District Attorney Bofill Duhé, who brought the indictment against Thibodeaux. The excessive bail set by the presiding judge would, in itself, indicate the extent to which favoritism and cheap political theater are very much in play in Iberia Parish.

Bob Mhoon, a native New Iberian now living in Arlington, Texas, penned a letter to the editor of the local newspaper. But the Daily Iberian has appeared somewhat reluctant to publish his letter, so LouisianaVoice is doing so here.

In June of 2018 the headline was “Thibodeaux indicted.” “charges include racketeering, theft, malfeasance in office.”

Most everyone knows Mike Thibodeaux and, for the most part, they are happy with his exemplary accomplishments during twenty-two years in office. I’ve read the charges and studied the detailed audit upon which they are based. The audit and the Clerk of Court’s response to detailed findings were presented to the parish council and accepted without concern.

One of the major responsibilities of the Clerk of Court and his Chief Deputy Clerk of Court is to continually update their knowledge of all applicable laws and policies, including the periodic changes that must be added to internal policy manuals.  Interestingly, all past audits and corrective responses to items flagged were satisfactory.

What happened next? The state auditor requested a State Police investigation and that report was forwarded to the district attorney. His decision was to present to the grand jury which found charges were appropriate and Mike was formally charged.

What was the impetus for criminal charges? According to Louisiana State Auditor records, a formal complaint was made to their office by the ex-Chief Deputy Clerk of Court; someone equally responsible for managing the department during past audits. Retribution?

Not a single penny of parish money was misappropriated by the Clerk of Court or his office. True, funds were moved between accounts; simply because that was how it was always done. These oversights were quickly corrected before the charges were initiated.

The Clerk of Court was shocked when he was indicted and the judge set bail at $200,000. In setting bail the court considers; severity of charges, the likelihood of jail, and defendant’s community ties. The last factor alone should have negated all others. The likelihood of him fleeing charges is infinitesimal.  His entire life has been in New Iberia with a loving family, and a lengthy, exemplary, career in local government. The bond was excessive!

How does favoritism come into play? I reviewed a number of Louisiana Legislative Auditor cases involving functions of the governor’s office. No one involved in these oversights was charged with any crimes!

Here is clear evidence of unfairness and favoritism. Homeland Security Finding. We identified 81 reimbursement requests where $3,309,036 (31.89%) worth of expenses were not supported by sufficient documentation. March 31, 2008, through December 31, 2016, we analyzed expense reimbursements totaling $925,837,580. We noted exceptions totaling $250,074,672 (27.01%). Louisiana Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness worked with the subgrantees to resolve $134,830,335 (53.92%) of the exception amount. Louisiana Department of Health; did not deposit approximately $2.8 million into the Fraud Fund between fiscal years 2012 and 2017 in accordance with state law. (Amount: $2,797,768), LDH incorrectly deposited $323,570 into the Medicaid Fraud Fund in fiscal year 2012 that should have been deposited into the Nursing Home Residents’ Trust Fund. (Amount: $323,570). Lastly, LDH spent $642,593 from the Medicaid Fraud Fund in fiscal year 2012 on software that could not be implemented due to system compatibility issues. (Amount: $642,593) There are hundreds more similar discrepancies available on the LLA website.

Mike has steadfastly supported the community and now desperately needs your help.  Make a quick phone call to the DA, expressing support for Mike. After seeing the Governor’s disorganization and auditor favoritism, Bo Duhe needs to exercise compassion and immediately drop the charges to free Mike from the unfair burden. Having to defend himself against unwarranted charges while paying an attorney large sums of money is simply wrong.

Why is the governor’s organization exempt from the law?

Bob Mhoon

Arlington, TX

 

Louisiana State Government has enough boards to construct a fair-sized house.

The state has an eye-popping 477 boards and commissions, according to the Louisiana Legislative Auditor’s ANNUAL REPORT to the Legislature released last month.

That compares to 287 for Arkansas and 217 for Mississippi. Texas, meanwhile, manages to get by on just 89.

But then, Texas probably does not have a need for an Alligator Advisory Council since that state apparently doesn’t have as many alligators in need of advice.

And it’s questionable as to the real need of a Boll Weevil Eradication Commission, since they’ve been eradicated for some time now.

There well may be a need for the Boxing and Wrestling Commission, however—especially during Louisiana’s often contentious legislative sessions.

But one has to question the effectiveness of the Child Poverty Prevention Council, given the fact Louisiana has one of the highest childhood poverty rates in the nation.

Then there’s the Drug Abuse Resistance Education (DARE) Advisory Board (and there’re certain places where board members DARE not enter).

But just to cover all the bases, we also have the Drug and Device Distributors Board, The Drug Control and Violent Crime Board, and the Drug Policy Board.

And Louisiana still has a huge drug problem, due in part perhaps to the report on the Louisiana Board of Pharmacy which noted that in 2016, there were 14,628 hydrocodone and oxycodone prescriptions missing from the Prescription Monitoring Program database.

There’s the Emergency Medical Services for Children Advisory Council, the Emergency Medical Services Certification Commission, the Emergency Response Commission, and the Emergency Response Network Board.

And I’m not even going to talk about the Crab Task Force.

I could go on, but in case you didn’t notice, I never even got out of the E’s on the list of boards.

For fiscal year 2018, the myriad boards collectively reported $1.3 million paid in board member per diems, $1.7 million for member salaries and $2.1 million for member travel expenses.

The number of boards and commissions, however, is just one area of concern covered in the 44-page report.

  • The LSU System did not have adequate controls in place over the preparation of its financial statements, resulting in errors of its 2017 financial report;
  • LSU Health Sciences Center (HSC) in Shreveport did not have adequate controls in place over federal, state and private grants and contracts to pursue collection of funds owed to it. The center reported $2 million in uncollected money from 2005 to 2017.
  • For the third consecutive year, the HSC Division (HSCD) and LSU did not have a final, signed agreement for all equipment used by the partner managing the University Medical Center New Orleans. Even though a lease agreement requires supplies and other items purchased by the State to be reimbursed by the private partner, repayment of $8.4 million remains outstanding (this is just one of the results of the Jindal privatization of state hospitals). Additionally, HSCD did not even attempt to collect a $163,544 debt from a contractor and HSCD has still been unable to locate movable property totaling more than $1.6 million associated with Earl K. Long Medical Center.
  • The Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) failed to maintain adequate control over its movable property, resulting in unlocated property and the incorrect reporting of an asset valued at $2 billion when the actual cost was $20,664.
  • Five state agencies oversee 78 tax incentives that resulted in the loss of approximately $1.1 billion in revenue in fiscal year 2017. Moreover, auditors found that 25 of the 78 tax incentive reports submitted to the Legislature by March 1, 2018, did not include information on whether the state received a positive return on its investment.
  • The Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (GOHSEP) Public Assistance Programs had $149.6 million in federal reimbursement requests that were not supported by sufficient documentation.
  • Louisiana spent about $5 million on lawsuits involving sexual harassment claims since 2009. State agencies do not have consistent processes in place to conduct reference checks of prospective employees and state law does not mandate training for employees on ways to identify, report and investigate sexual harassment.
  • The Louisiana Department of Health (LDH) did not deposit about $2.8 million into the Medicaid Fraud Fund in accordance with state law. LDH spent $477,000 from the fund in 2017 for salaries that did not appear to contribute to the prevention and detection of Medicaid fraud and abuse and the agency spent $643,000 from the fund in fiscal 2012 for software that was useless because of system compatibility issues.

Additionally, the Legislative Auditor’s office conducted 4,173 audits of local governmental services during 2018, most of those by private auditing firms under contract. “During the 2018 calendar year, local auditee reports contained hundreds of findings related to deficiencies in operations, controls, and compliance with laws and regulations,” the report says. These findings included:

  • Misappropriations and ethics violations;
  • Noncompliance with federal regulations in local governments’ administration of federal programs;
  • Noncompliance with bond covenants or loan agreements;
  • Noncompliance with state laws covering public bids, open meetings, untimely deposits, and late filings of financial statements;
  • Reconciliation of bank accounts;
  • Errors in accounting records;
  • Deficit fund balances.

And yet, precious little is ever heard from these reports. Oh, there is the occasional indictment, accompanied by a glowing, self-congratulatory press release from Attorney General Jeff Landry, but on the whole, zilch.

To paraphrase the quote mistakenly attributed to the late Illinois Senator EVERETT DIRKSEN: A million here and a million there and pretty soon you’re talking about real money.

Maybe the state needs to appoint another board or commission to study the problem of legislative apathy and inaction.

 

Folks, I’m not going to promise you health, eternal life, or wealth like one-time TV preacher/huckster Rev. BOB TILTON who once sent me a plastic bag with a few grains of sand “from the mountain where I am going to go to pray for you,” (question: if he was “going to go” there, the implication being he hasn’t been yet, how’d he get the sand beforehand?) but I can promise you that I will continue to do my level best to expose political hucksterism when and where I find it if you help support the efforts of LouisianaVoice with your contributions.

I don’t aspire to prey on people’s emotions like JOEL OSTEEN who peddles happiness and self-image in order to induce you to empty your wallet. Nor do I need your donations to help me purchase a $17.5 million jet like KENNETH COPELAND. That’s just not my style.

My style is to rely on the Biblical tenet of comforting the afflicted (Louisiana taxpayers) and afflicting the comfortable (elected and appointed officials who are trying to stick it to the rest of us).

I am currently working with my attorney in setting LouisianaVoice up as a 501(3)(c) non-profit so that your future contributions will be tax deductible. But for now, they ain’t.

Nevertheless, I humbly ask that you help in whatever manner you can, either by clicking on the yellow DONATE button to the right and paying by credit card or by mailing your check to:

LouisianaVoice

P.O. Box 922

Denham Springs, Louisiana 70727

As always, thanks so much for your support.

Tom

 

The Louisiana Legislative Auditor’s office, as required by law, issued its Report on Fiscal Deficiencies, Inefficiencies, Fraud, or Other Significant Issues Disclosed in Governmental Auditors for the first quarter of Fiscal Year 2019 last October.

And now, six months down the road, it’s a pretty good bet that no more than a handful of legislators, at best, have even glanced at the five-page REPORT that nine state agencies and one local agency for 17 deficiencies or irregularities totaling more than $245.7 million. Some of the deficiencies reported go back as far as 2008.

In fact, the smart money says that no more than a half-dozen of the 28 House members and 19 Senators who comprise the Joint Legislative Committee on the Budget have even picked up a copy of the report.

After all, there are campaign funds to be raised and lobbyists to be kept happy and one must have priorities.

And these are the ones who are charged with watching the purse strings on the state budget:

Joint Legislative Committee on the Budget (JLCB)

HOUSE
Henry, Cameron                           Chairman                          
Abraham, Mark                           Member                          
Abramson, Neil C.                           Member                          
Amedée, Beryl                           Member                          
Armes, James K.                           Member                          
Bacala, Tony                           Member                          
Bagley, Larry                           Member                          
Berthelot, John A.                           Member                          
Billiot, Robert E.                           Member                          
Carter, Gary                           Member                          
Chaney, Charles R.                           Member                          
Edmonds, Rick                           Member                          
Falconer, Reid                           Member                          
Foil, Franklin J.                           Member                          
Harris, Lance                           Member                          
Hodges, Valarie                           Member                          
Leger, Walt III                           Member                          
McFarland, Jack                           Member                          
Miguez, Blake                           Member                          
Miller, Dustin                           Member                          
Pylant, Steve E.                           Member                          
Richard, Jerome                           Member                          
Simon, Scott M.                           Member                          
Smith, Patricia Haynes                           Member                          
Zeringue, Jerome                           Member                          
Jackson, Katrina R.                           Interim Member                          
Stokes, Julie                           Interim Member                          
Barras, Taylor F.                           Ex Officio                          

 

SENATE
LaFleur, Eric                           Vice Chair                          
Allain, R. L. Bret                           Member                          
Appel, Conrad                           Member                          
Barrow, Regina                           Member                          
Bishop, Wesley T.                           Member                          
Donahue, Jack                           Member                          
Fannin, James R.                           Member                          
Hewitt, Sharon                           Member                          
Johns, Ronnie                           Member                          
Martiny, Daniel R.                           Member                          
Morrell, Jean-Paul J.                           Member                          
Tarver, Gregory                           Member                          
White, Mack “Bodi”                           Member                          
Chabert, Norbèrt N. “Norby”                           Interim Member                          
Morrish, Dan W. “Blade”                           Interim Member                          
Thompson, Francis C.                           Interim Member                          
Walsworth, Michael A.                            Interim Member                          
Alario, John                            Ex Officio                          
Long, Gerald                           Ex Officio                    

 

I base my opinion on the premise that had any of them read the report, they would—or should—be raising holy hell over such things as:

  • For the sixth consecutive report, the Department of Environmental Quality has not fully implemented effective monitoring procedures over the Waste Tire Management Program (WTMP) to ensure that waste tire date used to calculate subsidized payments to waste tire processors is reasonable. “We first reported weaknesses in controls over payments to WTMP processors in our engagement that covered fiscal years 2008 and 2009,” the report says. For the period from July 1, 2007, through June 30, 2017, DEQ paid out $99.4 million in subsidies to six waste tire processors.

Other major deficiencies cited included:

Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (Hazard Mitigation):

  • Expense reimbursements not supported by invoices, receipts, lease agreements, contracts, labor policies, time records, equipment logs HUD settlement statements, appraisals, elevation certificates, duplication of benefits verification, engineer plans inspection photographs or other documentation: $1.8 million;
  • Contracts and purchases did not comply with applicable federal and state procurement requirements: $1.47 million.

Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (Public Assistance):

  • Completed work not within the scope of an approved project: $2.3 million;
  • Expense reimbursements not supported by invoices, receipts, lease agreements, contracts, labor policies, time records, equipment logs, inventory records or other documentation: $40.1 million;
  • Contract and purchases did not comply with applicable federal and state procurement requirements: $11.95 million;
  • Work reflected in the expense reimbursements did not comply with applicable FEMA regulations: $9.4 million;
  • GOHSEP’s cost estimating tool and/or expense review form either omitted or contained duplicate and/or incorrectly categorized expenses: $956,000.

Attorney General:

  • The AG did not deposit money into the Fraud Fund in fiscal year 2016 in accordance with state law: $713,000.

Louisiana Department of Health:

  • LDH did not deposit money into its Fraud Fund between fiscal years 2012 and 2017 in accordance with state law: $2.8 million;
  • LDH incorrectly deposited money into the Medicaid Fraud Fund in fiscal year 2012 that should have been deposited into the Nursing Home Residents’ Trust Fund: $323,000;
  • LDH spent money from the Medicaid Fraud Fund in fiscal year 2017 for salaries that do not appear to meet the intended purpose of the Fraud Fund: $477,000;
  • LDH spent money from the Medicaid Fraud Fund in fiscal 2012 on software that could not be implemented due to system compatibility issues: $643,000.

Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority (Oil Spill):

  • Amounts requested/invoiced not supported by invoices, receipts, lease agreements, contracts, labor policies, time records, equipment logs

It’s somewhat puzzling when people like Reps. Cameron Henry (R-Metairie) and Taylor Barras (R-New Iberia) try to fight the governor’s budgetary proposals at every opportunity (including his attempt to increase teachers’ pay) but you never hear a peep out of them about a paltry $245 million.

And Henry just happens to be chairman of the JLCB and Barras just happens to be Speaker of the House.

As our late friend, C.B. Forgotston was fond of saying, “You can’t make this stuff up.”