You would think that after widespread cheating scandals swirling around student testing, Louisiana Superintendent of Education John White would be extra cautious to ensure the same embarrassment was not repeated here. People, after all, have been indicted in other places for the practice.
The Louisiana Department of Education (LDOE) has been sitting on the results of the LEAP, iLEAP and the LEAP Alternative Assessment Level 2 (LAA 2) tests for several weeks now and no matter what the official line to the contrary coming out of LDOE, the fact is those results were scheduled to be released Friday morning (May 16).
Now comes word from within the department that LDOE employees have balked at White’s demands to tweak the results for the Recovery School District (RSD) and this little development has thrown a wrinkle into the scheduled release of the test scores.
We have no way of knowing at this point whether or not the reports are true but when the test scores were not forthcoming as promised at 9 a.m. Friday, that certainly did not help White’s credibility. He already has been caught lying about departmental pay raises, hiring freezes and attempting to “take some air out of the room” in his testimony to a legislative committee over the awarding of more than 300 vouchers to a Ruston school with no desks, teachers, or facilities. So when release of the scores was delayed without any explanation except to say he would have a statement at 3 p.m., why should we be surprised?
The age-old tactic of releasing adverse statements and news stories late on Fridays, when many Capitol reporters have left for the weekend, has become a preferred and perfected practice for this administration and White apparently has learned well.
The 3 p.m. Friday announcement said that the test results would be released on Tuesday of this week. An LDOE official said that while the Friday “tentative release date” for the scores was on the calendar, there was never an official date for their release. Bull feathers, horse hockey and meadow muffins. John White is from the government and he’s here to help, the check is in the mail, and he’ll still respect us in the morning. Sorry, John, we’ve heard ‘em all before and we ain’t buying it.
While there are claims that last minute Legislature-mandated changes to the Minimum Foundation Program (MFP), the formula employed to allocate funding to the various school districts in the state, coupled with staff shortages at LDOE caused the delay, there’s no escaping the fact that LDOE has been sitting on these test results for weeks now. Moreover, do the same personnel perform work on extrapolating test data and the MFP? That would appear to be a stretch—even with staff shortages.
Those “staff shortages,” by the way, are no one’s fault but White’s. He has gutted the staff by drastically reducing the number of employees, the “in the trenches” workers who do the actual work, while bloating the department with unclassified, highly-paid administrative political appointees who appear to do little other than occupying reserved parking spaces in the Claiborne Building’s parking garage.
When your subordinates refuse to place their reputations on the line for your political agenda, the reasons for your delay in releasing the scores suddenly become much clearer.
Louisiana tests its students annually in English language arts, mathematics, science and social studies in third through eighth grades in order to measure whether students have gained the knowledge and skills in the subject for their respective grades.
The Louisiana Educational Assessment Program (LEAP) is the series of annual assessments in English language arts, mathematics, science and social studies for fourth and eighth grades. A criterion-based test, these tests are aligned to state academic standards.
The series of annual assessments administered in grades three, five, six and seven is known as the “integrated” Louisiana Educational Assessment Programs (iLEAP). It is referred to as an integrated LEAP because it originally combined a criterion-based component, which measured whether a student had mastered the academic standards, with a norm-referenced component (the Iowa Test of Basic Skills), which provided a percentile ranking of students. The iLEAP tests of 2013-14 no longer contain the Iowa portion and are criterion-based only.
It would be to the advantage of White, the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education and Gov. Bobby Jindal if the test scores reflected significant gains by students but word received by LouisianaVoice indicates that all is not well in the RSD and that White would prefer a rosier picture in the trouble-plagued district—if only those stubborn civil servants would cooperate.
But the obvious question here is: why would we expect good scores from the RSD anyway? RSD has been a stink hole of inefficiency, poor performance, overpaid administrators, missing equipment and waste since day one. Mediocrity is a goal to which the RSD can only aspire.
Word coming out of the department is that LDOE employees were asked to cook the RSD books but LDOE staff members have refused to become a part of yet another cheating scandal. And given what has already transpired in Philadelphia, Atlanta, Washington, D.C., Nevada, and other states, who could blame them:
- Former Washington, D.C. Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee, the poster child for school reform fraud, was fully aware of widespread cheating and even handed out bonuses totaling $1.5 million to teachers whose students showed significant gains before the cheating on standardized test answers by nearly 200 teachers in 70 schools became public knowledge and forced her out. She, however, landed on her feet and formed StudentsFirst, raking in millions of dollars from the likes of the Walton family, Bill Gates and Michael Bloomberg.
- Close on the heels of the D.C. cheating travesty was the early 2013 indictment of the former superintendent of Atlanta Public Schools and three dozen other administrators, teachers, principals and other educators for cheating—even after a similar state investigation two years earlier found similar cheating by nearly 180 educators in 44 Atlanta schools.
- In mid-April of this year, three Clark County (Nevada) School District employees were placed on leave after a state investigation found that adults altered answer sheets on standardized tests at a Las Vegas elementary school which in turn led to skyrocketing scores from one year to the next.
- Last week, less than a month after the Las Vegas revelations, an elementary school principal and four teachers were arraigned in connection with test cheating in the Philadelphia School District. The arraignments were the result of a grand jury investigation.
One child whose test results were changed, showed huge gains in reading comprehension and was promoted to the ninth grade even though her reading level was found to be still at a fifth grade level.
Cheating robs children of a good education and hurts kids and their families, the Pennsylvania attorney general said.
The reaction of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers was even more severe with the federation president issuing a statement that the union would not provide legal assistance for those charged.
Such, though, is the nature of school reforms implemented with so much emphasis on all the wrong things—standardized test scores at the expense of actual learning.
In the frenzy to improve national standings to enhance the résumés of politicians, bureaucrats and demagogues, they have fallen all over each other in attempts to put up stronger numbers while overlooking the most important element in education—the kids. It’s almost as if the frenetic efforts to improve test scores are being made for the benefit of the adults at considerable expense to the real education of children.
Perhaps a quote attributed to Albert Einstein, provided by Diane Ravitch, said it best: “I believe in standardizing automobiles. I do not believe in standardizing human beings. Standardization is a great peril which threatens American culture.”
Einstein said that people like Henry Ford, who advocated the standardization of both automobiles and people, “do not realize that the adulation they receive is due to the power of their pocketbooks on the force of their personalities.”
We have to wonder if Bill Gates, Michelle Rhee, the Walton family Michael Bloomberg, Bobby Jindal, John White or Chas Roemer ever read those words—or if they can even comprehend their importance or their implications.
And are our legislators paying attention at all?
Perhaps we should bring back the dunce cap—just for them.
Are they listening? Oh, you can bet your bottom dollar the legislators have been listening. Just In case you haven’t had the (non) pleasure to personally witness mr john white in action at the Capitol, let me paint a little picture for you: the legislators eat up his every word. He is quite talented at putting a negative Spin On every bill that could reverse some of the curse that our kids are dealing with.
Well, there are a bunch of pissed off moms who are sick of this horrible man’s BS. Read what we had to say, hours before ANY news source was able to get a story out because teachers reached out to us as soon as they heard:
http://louisianaparentsagainstcommoncore.blogspot.com/2014/05/leap-scores-withheld.html?m=1
What is so sad is that White, Roemer and jindal can get away with this foolishness and the legislature allows it. If the people elected by the majority can allow this evil to continue where are the good guys in all of this and what is happening to Louisiana, DC, other states and how do we fight it?
If theft is a felony, then shouldn’t attempted test score manipulation also be a felony?
Hello, EBR Parish DA, I’d like to report a criminal act by John White.
Because money is involved in SPS awards the manipulation by White IS a crime that he will have to pay for. Then there are the many suspect grants and contracts using taxpayer money. It’s all there in the record and White is truly absorbed in his own power and greed if he doesn’t believe that the public can and will seek retribution.
You fight it like this:
As usual Tom Aswell is “on point”
What’s happened to Mr. White’s recently fabricated concern about creating chaos for teachers and students? Grade advancement, summer school rosters, summer school staffing, and more are in the air until these LEAP/iLEAP scores are released. Plus, he wants to institute a new, untested test (PARCC) next year, yet he can’t even get the old one properly graded.
PS: We surely don’t want Mr. White to have a bad year on his résumé, do we? How’s he supposed to get a sweet lobbyist or ed-reform guru gig if his RSD looks bad…again? C’mon, cut the dude some slack. 😉
White can count on his reputation preceding him.
Not only that, Ben, there are schools in the state that have already finished the year. Students themselves don’t know if they’ve passed the 4th/8th grade until the results come in. Families may have to rearrange summer plans to accommodate retesting, and still have no idea.
Parents must refuse to retest until they are given the graded test and the opportunity to review it w r w/o the advice of a qualified teacher. ))
It’s unconscionable, Anonymouse. Just imagine what LDOE would do to a teacher, principal, or district superintendent if test materials weren’t turned in on time–not to mention IEPs, final grades, graduation numbers, and the like.
Amen, geauxteacher!
John White needs to go! I hope this will be investigated, but unfortunately, watching how he is protected, I don’t think it will be. I sure hope people wake up and not be as forgiving with this, just like they were when he released LA social security numbers without consent of parents. This needs to be BLASTED on every news outlet possible!
This new age of “accountability” only seems to extend beyond the citidel’s walls, extorting allegiance from the serfs, who for now are the teachers, administrators, and traditional public schools. This new way does not work and results in either 1) Good teachers being “put on a plan” and bullied out of the profession, or 2) Cheating or fudging. The ONLY fix is for the PEOPLE to rise up and DEMAND REASONABLE ACCOUNTABILITY MEASURES!
It is unreasonable to 1) Evaluate performance based upon one measure assessed on one day; 2) Force teachers to set SLTs (student learning targets) for their own accountability when they are not in possession of a crystal ball to predict even which HIGH STUDENTS will falter due to parental divorce, unemployment, illness, or any other debilitating event, 3) Force teachers to choose 80% attainment of grade level benchmarks that are “highly suggested and I’m not signing off on it if you are not amenable to it” learning goals.
Sixty percent of teachers across the state are now entering (listen for the angelic chorus): COMPASS DATA!!! Now, the forty percent of teachers who have made a run on antacids get to await (aren’t “demons” “turned angels”???): The Double-Whammy-Vammy!
I hope that people will take the opportunity in 2015 to repudiate this entire approach to governance.
I can’t wait for Jindal’s term to be over. Maybe then we can purge the state of the hand picked elitists who are not true public servants. And yes Mr. Roemer needs to go, he and the silver spoon in his mouth.
I have been a teacher in Jeff Parish for over 25 years. I have administered the iLEAP tests in 3rd grade for years. In the last several years, constructed response items have been added to each section. This school year, every section had a written response.
I have not been able to find out who is grading these thousands of written responses from LA’s 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 8th graders. Other testing companies advertise on Craig’s List and hire from Kelly Services! As students’ educational progress and teachers’ evaluations are determined by these results, I feel we
have a right to know just who is grading this component of the tests.
It does surprise me that Mr. White is trying to hide the facts. When we were giving the LEAP test, we teachers had to fill out a report if the student had more then 3 erasers on their papers! The school put the fear of God and permanent lost of Teaching License if any abnormality was suspected or found with the test. I work in the RSD and everybody is expecting miracles. We were suppose to take kids who were 2-4 years below grade level or more, and bring them up to grade level in a short time. With lack of materials, equipment and little or no support from parents. I’ve tried my best and will keep on trying.
Open your eyes, NOLA Teacher.
Jeff teacher – Good question. I filed the following FOIA. Check back with me.
As per Louisiana Public Information statutes, please provide the following:
This teacher submitted the following comment on line:
on May 18, 2014 at 1:19 pm | ReplyJEFF TEACHER
I have been a teacher in Jeff Parish for over 25 years. I have administered the iLEAP tests in 3rd grade for years. In the last several years, constructed response items have been added to each section. This school year, every section had a written response.
I have not been able to find out who is grading these thousands of written responses from LA’s 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 8th graders. Other testing companies advertise on Craig’s List and hire from Kelly Services! As students’ educational progress and teachers’ evaluations are determined by these results, I feel we have a right to know just who is grading this component of the tests.
Please provide the following in response to this query:
1. Contacts or agreements between LDOE/BESE and the company that grades or provides graders for Louisiana student constructed responses for the years 2010, 2011, 2013, and 2014.
2. Dollar amounts for each of these contracts/agreements and specifically fir the grading of the constructed responses.
3. If the contracts requested do not explain how these constructed responses are graded (computer or human), provide any documentation OR your explanation of same.
Lee P. Barrios, M.Ed., NBCT
Secondary English, Journalism, Gifted
178 Abita Oaks Loop
Abita Springs, Louisiana 70420
985-789-8304
http://www.geauxteacher.net
“If a child struggles to clear the high bar at five feet, she will not become a “world class” jumper because someone raised the bar to six feet and yelled “jump higher,” or if her “poor” performance is used to punish her coach.” – – CommonSense
http://tedxtalks.ted.com/video/The-Myth-of-Average-Todd-Rose-a
“I believe in standardizing automobiles. I do not believe in standardizing human beings. Standardization is a great peril which threatens American culture.”—— Albert Einstein
Don’t forget about the Tony Bennet, Indiana’s former education superintendent. While the people spoke, and he was ousted from his elected postion, he had to resign from his newly obtained Fla. education commissioner position when it was discovered that he had “cooked the books” back in Indiana to boost the letter grade of a charter school whose founder just happened to be a big repub. campaign donor. He should join your ed-reformer hall of shame.
[…] seems that in this instance, his Louisiana Department of Education (LDOE) underlings have refused to airbrush LEAP scores in order to create a false luster of behalf of […]
[…] seems that in this instance, his Louisiana Department of Education (LDOE) underlings have refused to airbrush LEAP scores in order to create a false luster of behalf of the […]
[…] https://louisianavoice.com/2014/05/17/learning-is-more-than-a-test-score-but-john-white-still-tries-t… […]
[…] offered no reason for the delay. However, by now, it is no secret that scores for White’s pet project, predominately-charter Recovery School District (RSD), […]
[…] “improvement” if students don’t improve on their own. My guess is he gave up on altering the test scores after word of this plan came to light, thus the reason for the delayed results, merged categories, lies about deadlines, and […]
[…] Unfortunately we now live in the internet age. What a three day week end now means is a little extra time to do what we kids used to call, surf. I did a little looking around and a little Googling. Funny thing, Tennessee wasn’t’ the only state having trouble getting those test scores out on time. Louisiana was having issues as well. (http://www.shreveporttimes.com/article/20140521/NEWS0401/305210041/Late-state-test-scores-schools-scrambling) It also seems like someone else utilizes the Friday news dump as well. (https://louisianavoice.com/2014/05/17/learning-is-more-than-a-test-score-but-john-white-still-tries-t…😉 […]
[…] upon the bru-ha-ha (see here and here and here) allegedly coming from the Louisiana Department of Education (LDOE) in the days between […]
[…] Analysis) report to Jessica Baghian who they recently moved over to Accountability and Assessment. As some of you may have recently heard, these sections had some whistleblower(s) who recently come forward and accused John White of asking […]
[…] the reports coming out of Louisiana, that their State Superintendent John White has been accused of cooking the books on the charter’s performance . Several whistle blowers within the Louisiana Department of Education refused to go along with […]