We are constantly encouraged to participate in our government.
Our civics teachers in high school drummed into our heads that we should get involved.
Write your representative or senators, we are told, because it’s the best way to make your thoughts known.
Our U.S. representatives and senators even have web pages on which we may contact them about a particular issue.
Do you really want to know just how effective it is to contact your representative or senator?
Do you truly believe a warm-blooded human actually reads your letter?
Are you interested in learning how difficult it is to get your message heard over the hum of the campaign money-counting machines in your congressperson’s office?
If your answer to the last three questions is yes, read on.
I recently went onto Rep. Garret Graves’s web page and clicked on the “Contact” link and sent him an email, the basis of which dealt with the 2016 flood.
I explained that like thousands of other victims, when seeking flood relief, I was directed by FEMA to the Small Business Administration table where I was given an application form for an SBA loan to repair damage to my home which took in 33 inches of water.
No one at FEMA or SBA bothered to explain that applying for a loan made me ineligible for a FEMA grant or even if I was offered a loan and refused it, the fact that it was offered automatically made me ineligible for a FEMA grant.
Read that again: even if I turned the loan offer down, I would be considered ineligible for a grant by virtue of the fact that a loan was offered.
I explained to Rep. Graves that my home was paid for at the time of the flood and that I did not carry flood insurance because we were in one of the highest-elevated parts of Denham Springs that had never even come close to flooding.
I also informed Rep. Graves that like hundreds, perhaps thousands of other victims, I was 76 years old, retired, and would never live to see my now brand-new $124,000 mortgage paid off.
I asked him to look into the possibility of loan forgiveness for the flood victims as had been done for other disaster victims and which was being considered [and subsequently approved] for potential recipients of SBA loans as part of the then-proposed $2 trillion coronavirus relief bill.
Here is the response I received from his office:
Thanks for taking the time to reach out to me about COVID-19. As we work to keep Louisianans safe and to minimize the economic damages associated with America’s response to this uniquely challenging threat, let’s keep this fact in mind: In Louisiana, we’ve seen our share of hurricanes, floods, and other disasters; people here know how to be resilient and pull through hard circumstances like this, and I’m confident that we are going to come out on the other side strong.
As you know, the United States is responding to a global outbreak of a respiratory disease caused by a new type of coronavirus, called COVID-19. Unfortunately, cases of COVID-19 and instances of community spread of the virus are being reported in a growing number of states. Following the recommendations of the Centers for Disease Control and the World Health Organization, the President of the United States declared the COVID-19 outbreak a national emergency.
Congress – and the entire federal government – is acting quickly to help Americans impacted by the coronavirus. We are working to provide regulatory relief, economic support, and innovations in our private industries to combat this threat. So far, the House and Senate have passed two major pieces of support legislation:
- On March 4, we authorized $8 billion in emergency funding for health research into COVID-19 to develop high-quality diagnostic kits, more effective treatment plans, and a vaccine to prevent the further spread of the disease.
- On March 18, President Trump signed a second piece of legislation called the Families First Coronavirus Response Act. This package was focused on individuals and families and ensures accessible testing, emergency paid leave, and support and flexibility for small businesses. You can read more about this bill here.
Our next step in the Congress is to pass legislation to deliver further assistance for our economy, including financial relief for those businesses and industries that are being hit the hardest by disruptions related to the pandemic response. As this bill comes together, my focus is on making sure the needs of South Louisiana’s families, individuals, and businesses are addressed.
This is a fast-evolving crisis, and things continue to change as new information becomes available every day. Please visit the coronavirus page on my website, where we are posting a running list of information, resources, and useful links to help you navigate this challenge. Additionally, please feel free to call our office or the Louisiana statewide call network (211) if you have additional questions or concerns. I appreciate you taking the time to reach out to me with your thoughts and hope you’ll stay in contact as this issue progresses.
Sincerely,
Garret Graves
Member of Congress
So, there you have it. If you have an issue that’s dear to your heart, just write your congressperson. [S]he’s there to help.
I got the same one – I wrote asked to make sure the bill just signed into law included artists, musicians, and others who have lost gigs of all types. The exact same letter.
Anyone else?
Whether from Graves or any other representative or senator sending you some B.S. computer-generated response to your concerns, we’d like to hear from you.
Make sure he gets a printed copy of this post, even if you have to deliver it personally, by hand.
I’m not proud to say I gave up writing/calling our U. S. Representative and Senators a couple of years ago when I realized the only effect, if that, was that a computer was keeping a record of what people were concerned about – seems like even that is not the case anymore, at least not with any precision.
I can report that 2 people in a political science class I am taking (and we are trying to keep going online) got very similar non-responsive letters from our senators and I remember the wording being almost the same as yours.
Apparently, the computers are now programmed to assume if you mention the virus that is your sole concern. At least when I used to write them the cut-and-paste responses addressed each the issues I wrote about. Like a certain head of a certain country, the computers now apparently believe they know everything and only address what they deem of significance in any case.
We have only one way to influence our nationally elected officials – the ballot box. It has never been more important that we use it.
Unfortunately Mr. Winham, too many voters have a problem discerning between candidates who will have their interest at heart and those who appeal to them in a manipulative fashion. So how do we educate the ignorant citizenry? I don’t have the answer.
Deplorables?
Me, either. I just think we HAVE to get people who see the dangers of this presidency to the polls. Trump supporters are hidebound in their support and I suffer under no illusions they will change their opinions or agree with my assessments of him. My only hope is there are more of us than them and that we will vote. I hope the recent upticks in his approval ratings during this crisis are aberrations that do not reflect how people will vote.
Why bother? I wrote both Kennedy and Cassidy regarding my misgivings about Betsy DeVos–we know how that ended. At the time, I thought DeVos was the worst Cabinet nominee (unqualified, political, a conservative religious agenda favoring vouchers and charters, not a friend of public education). It turns out that Barr is the worst and most dangerous. Trump’s Cabinet is a circus of inept and dangerous people.
Great stuff and I still write because it calms me down, well somewhat. Maybe you can help with a FIOA, re Elisabeth Crisps article about Graves attacking the the UCMJ back in NOv. Graves while riding with Trump got him to release a convicted soldier who had been legally convicted released from prison. Graves was so happy and said he was going to “pool our resources” to research sentences to see if they could get others out. Who the F is they and whose “Resources”. ???? ron thompson