Without getting into an overall critique of the Trump administration (I am already on record as to my feelings about him, so no need to repeat myself), I nevertheless feel compelled to address an issue that has arisen in recent days.
The Trump Justice Department, at his direction, is exploring the possibility of PARDONING military personnel convicted of war crimes in the Mideast, including SEAL Chief Edward Gallagher, Green Beret Major Matthew Golsteyn, a former Blackwater contractor and others.
Trump took up the matter supposedly after FAUX NEWS host ROGER HEGSETH repeatedly urged him to take the action.
No doubt such a move would get the approval of National Security Adviser John Bolton.
Setting policy on the advice of news reporters (and that includes ALL pundits whose job it is to report news, not make it) is bad enough, but this proposed action is ill-advised on so many levels that even U.S. military veterans are DISGUSTED by the very thought.
A former platoon leader in Iraq has also weighed in on the debate in a WASHINGTON POST story. And please, even if you agree with Trump about the Post, try to put those feelings aside and think about what is considered acceptable and unacceptable in the manner in which civilians are to be treated in wartime. This is an issue that transcends—should transcend—politics.
To issue pardons would send the wrong message about what this country stands for.
We are not Nazi Germany.
We are not Japanese soldiers slaughtering American GIs on the Bataan peninsula.
We’re better than that. At least, we’re supposed to be.
There’s another reason for opposing this insane line of action:
To uphold the heroics and to honor the memory of Hugh Thompson.
Born in Atlanta, Georgia in 1943, Hugh Thompson was the Army warrant officer who flew helicopters in Vietnam.
After the war, he settled in Lafayette, Louisiana, and flew ‘copters for Petroleum Helicopters, Inc. (PHI). He died of cancer in January 2006 in the VA Hospital in Pineville.
If you read nothing else in your life, read THIS ACCOUNT of The Forgotten Hero of My Lai and then decide for yourself if pardons are a good idea for war criminals.
If you don’t recognize his name, perhaps you’ll remember the name of LT. WILLIAM CALLEY.
The two men crossed paths on March 16, 1968, in what has become one of the darkest chapters of an ill-advised war that had no victors, only survivors.
Thompson happened upon the mass slaughter of Vietnamese civilians by Charlie Company of the U.S. Army’s 1st Platoon. He landed his helicopter and the following exchange took place between him and platoon commander Calley:
Thompson: What’s going on here, Lieutenant?
Calley: This is my business.
Thompson: What is this?
Who are these people?
Calley: Just following orders.
Thompson: Orders?
Whose orders?
Calley: Just following…
Thompson: But these are human beings, unarmed civilians, sir.
Calley: Look Thompson, this is my show. I’m in charge here. It ain’t your concern.
Thompson: Yeah, great job.
Calley: You better get back in that chopper and mind your own business.
Thompson: You ain’t heard the last of this!
Thompson subsequently left but returned and set his helicopter down between fleeing Vietnamese civilians and the pursuing Americans. He instructed his door gunners Specialists Lawrence Colburn and Glenn Andreotta to train their M-60 machine guns on the Americans and to cover him. “If these bastards open up on me or these people, you open up on them.”
His actions not only save the lives of 11 civilians at the scene, but when he reported the incident upon his return to base, his commander ordered Charlie Company to “knock off the killing.” His actions saved the lives of hundreds more Vietnamese.
So, was Thompson recognized as a war hero?
Nope. He was pilloried by members of the House Armed Services Committee, especially so by committee Chairman Mendel Rivers (D-S.C.), who actually proclaimed that Thompson was the only soldier at My Lai who should be punished and then attempted to have him court martialed. All the committee was interested in was covering up a massacre by American troops.
As Thompson told Calley, great job. Rep. Rivers and your fellow committee members
Thompson began receiving hate mail, death threats and mutilated animals on his doorstep.
It wasn’t until precisely 30 years later that Thompson, Andreotta and Colburn were awarded the Soldier’s Medal (Andreotta posthumously), the Army’s highest award for bravery not involving direct contact with the enemy. “It was the ability to do the right thing even at the risk of their personal safety that guided these soldiers to do what they did,” then-Major General Michael Ackerman said at the 1998 ceremony.
Calley, for his part, was eventually charged with the premeditated MURDER of 109 Vietnamese civilians. As it turned out, he was the ONLY ONE found guilty of murdering 22 civilians and sentenced to life imprisonment, a sentence that was reduced first to 20 years and then to 10 by the Secretary of the Army. He was paroled by Nixon in 1974 after serving only about three years.
Incredibly, he was considered by much of the public as a scapegoat in the entire affair.
Incredibly, National Security Adviser BOLTON for years has campaigned to convince other countries to sign the Article 98 agreements which says that the countries would not cooperate with the world court in the prosecution of American military personnel at the expense of American foreign aid if they did cooperate.
The Nazis would’ve loved to have had Bolton as their advocate at the NUREMBERG TRIALS.
And just so you know, Bolton, the quintessential war-monger who is constantly rattling swords, like Trump, was in reality, a DRAFT-DODGER during the Vietnam War, even writing in his Yale 25th reunion book, “I confess I had no desire to die in a Southeast Asian rice paddy. I considered the war in Vietnam already lost.” So, to him, it’s okay to send others to die for his political ambitions so long as he doesn’t have to answer the bell himself.
That would qualify him as a chicken hawk.
But I digress. To pardon these war criminals would be to dishonor the courage of Hugh Thompson and his two gunners, Lawrence Colburn and Glenn Andreotta.
They deserve better.
In the immortal words of Pogo: “We have met the enemy and he is us.”
Thanks for this story. Trump would love an obedient military that follows his orders regardless of their morality.
The Secretary of Education’s brother owns Blackwater. I wonder if money might have something to do with Trump’s interest in pardoning war criminals.Trump said he could fire a gun on 5th Ave. in the middle of the day and not lose support. Pardoning war criminals doesn’t seem so egregious given everything we know about the current White House Oval Office occupant.
Yes, Betsy Devos’s brother did own Blackwater, but does no more. I think the heat got to be a little too much for him.
Yes, John Bolton, a member of the Bush administration along with Cheney and the other Neo-Cons who got us into the Iraq war and the subsequent catastrophic consequences. And now itching to get us into a war with Iran. Surprisingly even Trump, so far, has ignored him.
Have you ever been to war sir?
You have no idea what goes on to those, who all by the way are sent by their superiors to do a job they were trained to do.
I was in the military during Vietnam. I did not go to ‘Nam, but I also did not dodge the draft. And I lost a friend in Vietnam, so don’t try to lecture me.
And let me tell you something right now, Mr. Super Patriot, it doesn’t matter a damn bit if I’ve been to war or not—war crimes are war crimes. Killing is killing and rape is rape, no matter which side does it. The tone you take seems to defend the Bataan Death March and Nazi war crimes—or do you reserve the absolution of unwarranted killing just for Americans? If so, you’re a hypocrite.
Yes, our soldiers were sent there to do a job but that was NOT part of their job description. As a matter of fact, the defense given by the Nazi defendants at Nuremberg was that they were “just following orders.”
Don’t you dare try to defend those people for what they did. That makes you no better than them.
And as Americans, we’re supposed to stand for a little more than that.
Tom thanks for this post. My husband and I along with two friends were talking about this massacre just yesterday. A sad commentary in our nation’s history.
Tom reply to Goose “I was in the military during Vietnam. I did not go to ‘Nam, but I also did not dodge the draft. And I lost a friend in Vietnam, so don’t try to lecture me”.
I do not agree with this article or your reply, I thank you for your service and I’m sorry for your loss but you have no idea what happens in a combat situation especially under the circumstances these men where in. Each individual’s situation is different and you’re putting it under one and that’s not fair at all.
Thanks and I cried again, thinking of Chief Warrant Thompson, no kin. The latest incident with the Navy crew on USS Wasp is beyond belief, (patch,”Make Aircrew Great Again” with Trump’s pic) and all within 24 hours, the story of moving The carrier John McCain, makes me mad as hell. I am writing my Coward Congressman, Ralph the Christian Abraham, who is still 100% behind Trump requesting he keep me informed of the Navy investigation of these clearly illegal actions. If there is a “cover-up”, look no further than our own GOP Congressional delegation. ron thompson