In 2013, the Louisiana Legislature passed and Gov. Bobby Jindal signed into law House Bill 703 which mandated that any state unclassified (appointive) employee earning $100,000 or more must be a bona-fide resident of the gret stet of Looziana.
The bill, which would become Act 264 of 2013 and which now goes by Louisiana Revised Statute 42:31, passed the HOUSE easily enough by a 70-20 margin with 15 members ducking out on the vote.
In the SENATE, however, it was quite another story with the bill squeaking through by a razor-thin 20-17 vote with two senators joining their 15 counterparts in the House in not voting.
The author of HB 703? That would be then-State Rep. John Bel Edwards.
Here are the specific provisions of the ACT:
- Notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, any person hired or employed in an unclassified position as defined by the State Civil Service Commission, and whose annual salary or rate of compensation is equal to, or exceeds one hundred thousand dollars, shall, within thirty days of being hired or employed at such salary, provide proof to his public employer that he has been issued a Louisiana driver’s license and that all vehicles registered in his name are registered in Louisiana. This requirement shall be deemed a qualification for the position for which the person was employed or hired, and for the duration of the person’s employment in the event the person’s salary is increased and the requirements of this Section are triggered.
- All government agencies which hire or employ any person in an unclassified position as defined by the State Civil Service Commission, whose annual salary or rate of compensation is equal to, or exceeds one hundred thousand dollars, shall verify that such person has been issued a Louisiana driver’s license and that all vehicles registered in his name are registered in Louisiana. The public employer shall verify the employee meets this requirement for the duration of this person’s employment.
- Any person hired or employed in an unclassified position who does not meet the requirements of this Section, or who no longer meets the requirements of this Section, shall be removed and terminated within thirty days of the public employer learning such person does not meet the requirements of this Section.
Credit for the introduction and subsequent passage of the law has to go to the late C.B. Forgotston who spearheaded a one-man campaign against state government parking garages crammed with vehicles bearing out-of-state license plates.
C.B. took it as a personal affront that Louisiana tax dollars were being used to hire employees from other states who wouldn’t even bother to register their vehicles in Louisiana. His reasoning was the workers were perfectly willing to take money from the state but weren’t willing to pay their fair share of taxes by simply registering their cars here.
One of the biggest offenders, he learned, was the Louisiana Department of Education (LDOE).
Of course, not all the out-of-state employees were pulling down a hundred grand a year but there was this one guy that LouisianaVoice had occasion to write about.
His name was David Lefkowith, though his friends just call him Lefty.
When they see him, that is. Trouble is, he is considered a ghost by some of his co-workers who assumed he was long gone from LDOE. That’s because he doesn’t appear at the LDOE offices in the Claiborne Building across from the State Capitol.
You see, Lefty resides in Los Angeles and commutes to Louisiana if and when he has occasion to drop in to pick up an Enterprise rental at Louis Armstrong Airport in New Orleans and visit educational centers in Houma, Natchitoches, Lafayette, and Shreveport—but rarely Baton Rouge.
When LouisianaVoice first had occasion to write about Lefty back in 2012, he was knocking down $145,000 a year as something called the Director of the Office of Portfolio.
Act 264 of 2013 threw a monkey wrench in State Education Superintendent John White’s decision to pay Lefty $145,000 and when LouisianaVoice did a story recently about all the unclassified employees at LDOE pulling down $100,000 or more per year, a couple of LDOE employees expressed curiosity to LouisianaVoice as to why his salary was cut $45,000, to $100,000. LEFKOWITH IS NUMBER 197 on the list provided LouisianaVoice.
Well, truth be told, it was cut $45,000.10 to $99,999.90. That put him at a dime below the $100,000 threshold and allowed him to slither under the door.
That is a little trick White probably learned from Jindal who had a cute habit of issuing contracts of $49,999 in order to avert the requirement for proposals, or bids, for all contracts of $50,000 and above.
Still, commuting back and forth between California and Louisiana on a $100,000 salary doesn’t make much sense. It just doesn’t seem a sound fiscal decision unless LDOE pays for his flights back and forth.
Not so, says White.
I made a public records request for all expense payments made to Lefty and I also sent the following email to White:
From: Tom Aswell
Date: Friday, May 25, 2018 at 10:51 AM
To: John White <John.White@la.gov>
Subject: LEFKOWITH
John, for an employee no one in LDOE seems to remember seeing around the office, you certainly have paid him quite a tidy sum in travel and lodging expenses. I have a couple of questions in that regard:
- How is he allowed to be a full-time employee of LDOE (at $100K per year) and reside in California?
- What are his precise duties at LDOE. Please be specific?
- What are his qualifications that you are apparently unable to find in a Louisiana resident?
- Did you know him before he was brought into LDOE?
- Does LDOE withhold state income taxes for Louisiana or California?
To his credit, White responded rather promptly, the very next day (a Saturday), in fact:
From: John White <John.White@la.gov>
Sent: Saturday, May 26, 2018 11:02 AM
To: Tom Aswell
Subject: Re: LEFKOWITH
Here is the web site that lists what Dave has developed and leads at the Department: https://www.louisianabelieves.com/courses/all-things-jump-start.
Dave attended Yale University as an undergraduate and Stanford University for business school. He spent more than 30 years as a management consultant across a wide array of industries. The work outlined above is unique among states and speaks to his capacity to lead the mission with which he has been charged. I was not familiar with him prior to becoming state superintendent.
Dave pays taxes in both states and is reimbursed for work-related travel within the state, as other state staff are. He pays his own commuting costs.
Thanks for the note.
John
As for Lefty’s management consultant duties, one of those was an ill-fated plan, uncovered by reporters Michael Pollock and Chris Davis of the Sarasota (Florida) Herald-Tribune (Davis would move on to become leader of a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative team at the Tampa Bay Times in St. Petersburg).
In 1998, when Jeb Bush was running for governor of Florida, Enron, then a fast-rising Houston energy broker, was in the process of diversifying into the potentially profitable new field of water supply privatization through a subsidiary called Azurix Corp.
Secretary of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) David Struhs, a Bush appointee, was simultaneously promoting two concepts on behalf of Azurix: auctioning off blocks of water to the highest bidders and obtaining underground water and storing it for later withdrawal through a process called aquifer storage and recovery (ASR).
Enron sank $900 million in Azurix, hoping to duplicate the proposed action in two other states, California and Enron’s home state of Texas, as well as in South America. Ultimately, however, Enron lost $500 million when the project failed to materialize, eventually selling what was left of the company in 2001 to American Water Works as a precursor to the eventual collapse of Enron.
Struhs also pushed another project to deregulate energy in Florida and to open the state to competition by allowing companies to build power plants, using existing power lines for the purpose of selling electricity to the highest bidding utility or other customers.
Standing shoulder to shoulder with Struhs was his good friend, David “Lefty” Lefkowith, president of Canyon Group, Inc., of Los Angeles.
Back in 1991, President George H. Bush named 23 industrialists and environmentalists to the President’s Commission on Environmental Quality and named Struhs to run the commission. One of the 23 commission appointees was then-Enron CEO Kenneth Lay.
When Bush lost his re-election bid to Bill Clinton in 1992, Struhs went to work for Lefkowith as vice president of Canyon Group. Lefkowith has represented as many as 60 different electric power companies through his company.
By 1998, Struhs was working for Jeb Bush and Lefkowith was on board with the ill-conceived Florida water privatization project. “I don’t think water is so damn special,” he said at the time. “If you let markets take over, you’d find water was cheaper, there would be more of it, and customers would be better served.” He neglected to explain how water quantity would increase.
Fast forward to 2002 and Struhs and Lefkowith were back at the forefront of market manipulation in Florida at the behest of Jeb Bush, but by now, their dealings were with electric power companies. Struhs was DEP Secretary and Jeb Bush had set up Energy 2020 Commission, a group assembled to study deregulation.
This time when Struhs brought him in as a consultant, Lefkowith was given unlimited access to all the emails of Bush’s Energy 2020 Commission members and staffers even though most of the 2020 commissioners never heard of him, never saw him (sound familiar?) and never knew he access to their correspondence.
On Feb. 4, 2001, Struhs’ deputy chief of staff, Mollie Palmer, ordered a half-dozen top DEP employees to start sending Energy 2020 Commission documents to Lefkowith with emails from Energy 2020 Chairman Walter Revell or from commission executive director Billy Stiles to be “forwarded to Lefty upon receipt.”
After receiving a copy of that memo, Pollock and Davis requested copies of all documents sent to Lefkowith but DEP officials responded that no documents existed. (That sounds much like the responses received by Capitol News Service from the Division of Administration and from the Louisiana governor’s office.)
“Who is this guy to get this information?” asked Florida Democratic Party Chairman Bob Poe. “From the tone and tenor of these emails and communications, he is directing energy policy (for the state). What authority does he have to do that? And for what purpose?”
Democratic State Sen. Kip Campbell of Tarmarac was even less forgiving of the practice. “Suppose I was sending letters to Struhs, like ‘here is my thought process on what we are going to do legislatively.’ And Lefkowith knows this ahead of time. Lefkowith might be working for Calpine and all those other companies and selling that knowledge for profit. I’d be willing to wager he probably was.”
Lefkowith also attended strategy sessions with Gov. Jeb Bush to discuss findings of the Energy 2020 Commission.
In addition, he lobbied Florida utility representatives in private meetings on the issue of building power plants in order to broker power sales.
He would later use the information he had obtained as confidant to Struhs and Jeb Bush to wrangle a consulting job with the Florida PSC.
So, yes, Lefkowith has worked with a lot of different entities but appears to have trouble remaining at one job for very long.
Now about White’s claim that Lefty pays his own commuting costs.
A check of his travel, lodging and meal expense reports provided by LDOE pursuant to our public records request turned up a couple of interesting tidbits, not the least of which was that the records appear to be incomplete with Lefkowith claiming many days of travel in Enterprise vehicles but hotel expense records that can only be described as spotty and sporadic with a lot of gaps. Accommodations for days at a stretch are unaccounted for.
From 2013 through current available 2018 dates, travel records show that LDOE has shelled out more than $21,880 for auto rentals, meals, lodging, and airplane flights to Austin, Texas, Cincinnati, and New Jersey.
On one occasion, on September 3, 2013, he drove an Enterprise rental vehicle 833 miles from New Orleans to Houma and Shreveport and back and even though he was in a rental, he charged LDOE for 99 miles at 51 cents per mile, collecting $50.49 in mileage. (Note: at the time, state regulations allowed employees to be reimbursed for a maximum of 99 miles traveled in personal vehicles as a means to encourage them to drive state vehicles. Regulations do not permit mileage payments while driving rentals.)
In July 2017 Lefkowith rented an Enterprise vehicle for 21 days, paid for by LDOE, and drove the car, a Chrysler Pacifica, from his Los Angeles home to New Orleans, a distance of 1,169 miles on your dime—$609.94 in dimes, to be precise.
So much for White’s claim that Lefkowith pays his own commuting expenses.
For that matter, the idea of paying his own commuting expenses on a $100,000 (oops, sorry. $99,999.90) per year salary just doesn’t make sense.
It’s enough to make one wonder just how many expense reports requested by LouisianaVoice were not forthcoming.
Surely any omissions were simply oversights.
Letter of the law….spirit of the law…fraud is fraud. Perhaps the Inspector General, the Legislative Auditor, the Ethics Commission, and legislators should take note.
Perhaps, but will they?
I’m sure the salary amount is simply coincidental with the law’s limit. Further, much like the argument that rests on what “is” is, commuting costs are a matter of interpretation and certainly don’t include his in-state travel. And, to bring up things that happened 20 years ago is certainly unfair – after all, paying attention to history in Louisiana, or the U. S., for that matter, is a retrograde practice to be avoided. This man is apparently worth every cent of his Louisiana income and has generously foregone $45,000.10 of his true value to us.
So, ease up, and, as that old hymn says, “Trust and obey, for there’s no other way, to be happy…” here.
As a Louisiana business owner, someone who business degree was majoring in the world view from 20000′ of economics and a lifetime Louisianan, and a member of the press club among other civic groups, it is my belief that it is just these continuous examples of SHENANIGANS, reminders to the public each time seen, spoken to or about ex.. (Jay Dardenne’s lifetime $7000 per month retirement INCREASE or Sen Cassidy’s sisters state employment, or former Sen Vitters wife’s lifetime judge job, as if no one else if qualified – maybe no one else stood by and let her spouse outright mislead about the status of their relationship..)
I have come to the conclusion these continuous affronts defer the average Louisianan from any support that would move Louisiana to the track of success just the top 50% of states enjoy in the measurements that define quality of life and of which Louisiana’s failure to achieve our potential only diminishes our nations accomplishments. So now and I will continue to ask PAR and the Governor and his staff why, as a state with a population smaller than one of Texas cities, why don’t you submit/propose a budget that would lead us to the success of the top 50 states (100% certified teachers, full funding for universities, medical school excellence instead of mediocrity)?
How does one accomplish a high goal if one shoots for the minimum as is represented by the actions in our legislature just today? And once again just back from the largest wind electric generator state in the nation, the headquarter of the worlds largest oil company, the headquarters of Cane’s, Smoothie King and the all the rest you just don want to know, Texas again. And no they cant reference anything from “the split” nor do they call anything “new” (bridge) that is 40 years old. and YES they pay a lot more in Taxes, as Jay Dardenne referenced recently answering TX vs LA questions for the Press Club. Long past time for us to change. Remi DeLouche Baton Rouge La.
The reason the governor doesn’t present the budget you suggest is (as you surely know) the tremendous amount of money such a budget would require and the unwillingness of many, particularly the legislature’s conservatives led by Harris and Henry, to support taxes for even the mediocre level of services currently provided, much less those of which we could be proud.
It’s a shame the time is long gone when it was possible to do what LBJ did in 1965 to get Medicare passed – shield the costs – and now it would be political suicide to take it away. If, by whatever means, we were ever able to have an adequate, stable budget that provided things we could take pride in (as Texans have always done), going backwards would be hard.
JBE does not seem to have a clue as to how negative reports (like the one about the Louisiana Highway Safety Commission in today’s ADVOCATE) directly lead and feed the public’s perception of how well Louisiana is being run. When is the last time you heard him say anything about concrete things he is doing to prevent waste, fraud, and abuse in state government? My answer would be never, but I may have missed something.
Surely JBE is not so naive as to believe people trust him enough to assume he is doing something behind the scenes to better manage state government. If he is holding his appointees responsible and accountable he needs to publicly demonstrate it. If he doesn’t the Harrises, Henrys and [J. N.] Kennedys of the world will always win – and the citizens will always lose whether they realize it, or not.
I am reminded, once again, of the joke EWE told many years ago about his first campaign for Governor: As he approached a circle of guys sitting around a pot-bellied stove in a country store, he said, “The 2 biggest problems facing Louisiana are ignorance and apathy” – to which one of the guys quickly replied, “Well, I don’t know and I don’t care.” That joke seems to sum up our problem today and nobody is trying to fix it. Instead, it is always SSDD here in Louisiana.
PS Forgot to mention that Gov Edwards was ELECTED through his personal INTEGRITY he was going to change these SHENANIGANS. Donald Trump can call out anything, about anything, its time Gov Edwards calls out and where ever possible step in and stop these abuses. State Police, Angolia, etc behind, its time he does so if he want a legacy that he managed OK and instead is desirable to be remembered… Remi DeLouche
If leading the charge in the “gret stet of Looziana” for Career and Technical Education is occasion to take half-baked information and apply it as so much kindling for the burning at the stake of Dave Lefkowith, something is seriously wrong.
Slow news day? I think not: there’s been plenty happening in the legislature during these last three sessions to provide more than enough fodder for a sleepy little blog. Stories just waiting to be told about Representatives standing defensively on the House floor encouraging non-profits to break the law with illegal lobbying practices, and Senators who publicly announce that they no longer serve at the will of the people… Ya know, important things that people care about.
Part of the problem with these tiresome old shots at “Lefty” is this: in order to be a true “disrupter” or heck, even a reporter “worth your salt”, one must actually research the facts. One cannot simply regurgitate hearsay and sprinkle in some pieces of decades old news articles (themselves, inaccurate/unfounded) to support their point. (Ahem, that’s to you, Tom.)
The bottom line is this: Dave Lefkowith has done more to advance Career and Technical Education in Louisiana than any other person on payroll at LDOE; and that’s not at all a dig at LDOE employees.
It is painfully obvious that Tom Aswell took, at best, a shoddy stab at due diligence when John White produced the requested information in re: Dave Lefkowith’s work. Otherwise, he wouldn’t have been able to “impartially” skate past this tiny, little piece of information: https://www.louisianabelieves.com/newsroom/news-releases/2017/01/11/louisiana-awarded-$2-million-to-improve-career-education
“Lefty” did this. By all means, grab the matches!
For once, a product of Louisiana’s education system is leading the nation… I don’t know about you, but I think that’s $609.94 of Louisiana tax-payer’s money uncharacteristically well-spent.
There is another “little” educational endeavor, led by “Lefty”, and found in the information John White provided, that might be of interest to Mr. Aswell; perhaps he should take a look at the Micro-Enterprise Credential, the first ever Career Pathway in Entrepreneurship that culminates in an Industry–Bearing Credential… (Psst! Entrepreneurship, ya know, the economic engine of Louisiana’s economy?!)
Or, we could, in our characteristically uninformed way, reach for a bellows…
The very headline for the Louisiana Voice piece is wildly inaccurate, irresponsibly inflammatory, and dies an embarrassing death at the hand of reprehensibly lax research skills.
If we citizens actually care to trifle with such things, here are the facts:
It is a minimum of 1,894 miles from Los Angeles to New Orleans no matter how you slice it.
The mileage Dave Lefkowith expensed in July 2017 was accrued completely in Louisiana as he traveled from the Louis Armstrong International airport (where his plane from LA landed) to Shreveport, Lafayette and back to New Orleans over the course of three weeks to provide Super Summer Institute training for teachers from more than 43 parishes in Louisiana, driving the bulk of those miles on weekends in order to personally set up each training room.
You see, in Louisiana, if an educator is to teach courses for a specific Career Pathway, they must first be credentialed to do so.
More than 200 Louisiana educators earned their credential to teach Micro-Enterprise during those trainings, led by “Lefty.” At a minimum, more than 6,000 students (including At-Risk, Under-served, and Students with Disabilities) now have access to this Career Pathway in just the first two years that follow teacher certification.
Somebody grab the lighter fluid.
For lack of an accurate headline, it would seem, then, that Mr. Aswell’s assertion is that telecommuting is a crime. I hate to muddle the warmongering with more actual data, but there’s been a 115% increase in telecommuting over the last 10 years, and 43% of the U.S. workforce currently work remotely. In fact, ironically, the headquarters for Louisiana Voice is …Tom Aswell’s Denham Springs home. (http://crawfishreport.com/2016/08/louisiana-voice-is-underwater/)
I’m sorry, what’s the headline again? Something about glass houses?
Giving credit where due, Tom does bring up one good question: for $99,999.90 WHY WOULD a person pay for their own “commute”, take a cut in pay and plan NOT to receive one penny in retirement from the job? “Hardly seems worth it” is right…Unless of course that person actually wanted to do some good for the state and had the personal means to cover his own state-to-state travel expenses.
Before setting alight another conflagration, Mr. Aswell would do well- and I daresay better serve Louisianans- were he to check his facts. And where education is concerned, try asking an educator!
Seriously? You are really going to compare telecommuting from Denham Springs (and how do you know it’s “telecommuting?”) with telecommuting from Los Angeles? Just sayin’…